Season 23 International Free Agent Report
1. Montreal Maroons, $28.2 million
Eliezer Perez
Montreal must either of thought highly of 18 y/o Perez or had little confidence in the upcoming IFA crop. Young Eliezer was the first star IFA pitcher to show up and the Maroons took no chances as they spent $5.1 million more than they have ever spent on one IFA to lock him up. This is the 3rd consecutive season that they have used the overwhelming majority of their prospect cash on a Pitcher. In the past 2 seasons they have elected to shovel buckets of money that they have at their disposal to Relief pitchers. This signing -like the previous seasons signing- seems to have landed the Quebec based franchise an elite arm adept at preserving leads and keeping the team in games that they are behind in. Perez should be able to only contribute 30-35 pitches every other day, though with his projected stuff, that might be good enough for 3+ innings. All of his pitches have progressed nicely during his full season at Low A. His slider and cut FB need some re-fining to be used regularly as a set-up or strikeout pitch in the majors. Perez's money pitch is the 4 seam FB. The only thing that should be able to hurt this athlete is his lack of ability to keep that sphere shaped white thing out of the air, however if his Low A numbers are any indication (2HR allowed in 40+ innings) Maroon fans have yet another stud to cheer for at the stadium less than affectionately referred to as "The Big O"
2. Louisville Sluggers, $27.9 million
Ezequiel `Zeke` Manzanillo
This is the first season in 8 years that the Lobsters have made a significant financial commitment to a position player through IFA, when they shelled out $15.4 million in bonus money to Santo Figureoa. Like Montreal, Louisville spent more this season on one player than they ever have. In fact, Manzanillo's bonus is $9 million more than the previous title holder Oswaldo Rodriguez. The only ballclub representing the moonshine state, like many other clubs, they love what this 4-5 tool Dominican is all about. Though being groomed as a SS at Low A, his 51 Errors in 91 games implores me to go out on a limb to predict that Zeke will play above average defence at either CF, 2B or 3B when he inevitably makes it to "the show" His bat is what should be worth the price of admission at Louisville Slugger Field and visiting ballparks regardless of where he plays. Zeke already has better plate vision than most current major league infielders. This young right-handed hitter will almost without a doubt be a superb contact hitter, capable of facing righties as effectively as south-paws. If that isn't already enough to please a manager, Zeke will make the lives of pitchers and catchers miserable with his speed and baserunning. There may be 2 factors that keep this dude from being a top 10 player in the bigs and that is his lack of durability and power. Manzanillo only managed to hit 10 homers last season and if there isn't significant improvement in his durability, he will only be able to play in approximately 120 games, though to be sure, they will be 120 exciting games.
3. Cincinnati Red Army, $23.1 million
Rigo Sandoval
With the exception of the past 2 seasons, The Red Army Franchise have rarely been able to convince ownership to commit a large portion of their operating budget to IFA spending. In fact, the last time they spent significant money on an IFA was back in season 9 when they snatched up Tony Servet for $16.8 million. Other than Servet, Vin Castillo (now in the twilight of his career) and 3 time Gold Glove CF, 2 time All Star Pedro Cedeno are the only biggish IFA signings by this Title-less Rust-Belt situated Franchise. GM Douch La Rouche has seemingly been taking a risky approach to signing IFAs. Over the past 2 seasons he has waited almost to the end of the signing period, each time lucking out by signing a gem and not being stuck with a huge chunk of prospect cash having nobody worth spending it on. The 19 year old, brother of star Football (Soccer) striker Luis Alonso, from Victoria Mexico grew up idolizing 2 of the best pivots in the history of the game Joe Morgan and Roberto Alomar. Though his bat closely resembles the formers, his defence is not nor will it ever be in the realm of the latter. Sandoval has good range and a decent glove. His arm is his main weakness, especially when it comes to accuracy. The only other blight on his resume might be base-running. Cincinnati will likely take a patient approach with the late season signee's development as he was assigned to Low A for the playoffs where he won a Championship. He is expected to play 2B at High A with a bunch of The Red Army's prospects this season. Cincinnati fans will be looking for improvement from Rigo defensively, though their main concern is likely that his major league ready bat improves leaps and bounds. There is no reason why this guy shouldn't hit at least above .280 in the majors, and stepping up to the plate at the "matchbox" that is The Great American Ballpark, hit easily 30 homeruns and maybe as many as 50.
4. Vancouver Vampire Bats, $22 million
Olmedo `Bob` Villa
The first significant IFA position player to show up in Season 23, Olmedo "Bob" Villa signed for $22 million. Like The Red Army, the V-Bats are relatively new to spending large amounts of prospect money on IFAs. Their only other large purchase was in Season 21 when they laid out $17.5 million in bonus cash for Maicer Reyes. Villa will not blow you away with his defensive abilities from LF, though his right handed bat will make up for those short-comings. He split time between Rookie ball and Low A, hitting over .300 at both levels. He also took advantage of his wheels, victimizing pitchers and catchers for 22 bags in a mere 80 games. Though with a small sample size, it is worth noting that he hit .375 in the Low A playoffs. Not blessed with great power, this pull hitter should improve to the point where he could hit 10-15 homers a season depending on how many ABs he gets. His greatest strength is his ability to make contact, as evidenced by his minor league numbers. He has also shown an above average ability to bunt for an 18 y/o. Scouts like his ability to handle both lefties and righties, and despite his deficiencies as a fielder it looks like Vancouver made a safe and solid investment.
5. Atlanta Spartans, $17.2 million
Jose Delgado
What looks to be possibly the second best relief pitcher in the Season 23 IFA pool signed for a $17.2 million bonus and an invite to spring training. The Spartans will need Jose's control to get significantly better. Delgado spent all of last season at High A throwing 20 innings over 11 appearances. In his limited action, he amassed 12 Strike Outs and 11 Base on Balls giving him an unimpressive WHIP of 1.60 and a 5.66 ERA. The Spartans should take heart in the fact that statistics (especially minor league stats) have little bearing on how someone will perform in "the show" However, they should be concerned that his durability and stamina are low, and that even at the tender age of 18, Jose has had a lot of health troubles. Mr. Delgado was signed near the end of the IFA signing period, Atlanta for that reason is likely pleased to have gotten him as opposed to nobody. Atlanta should have a better than average set-up man in their bullpen of the future if Delgado can stay off the DL and get his control close to his other abilities.
6. Nashville Catfish, $16.3 Million
Bartolo Nieto
Nashville grabbed this 18 y/o CF/2B from Cotui of the Dominican Republic. Nieto is an average defender with potential to be very good. His best attribute is clearly his power, which for a man of his age and who plays in the middle of the field, is off of the charts. His glove and base-running abilities should improve enough to be, at the very least, adequate for the big leagues. Unfortunately, all is not roses in the Music City. Nieto is far from a contact hitter by nature, despite his .349 average in rookie ball. He did wear a couple of golden sombreros last season, striking out 22 times in 109 at bats. Despite this, Nashville has to be happy with the ten doubles, three triples, seven homers and thirty RBI in his 1st professional season. The crystal ball foresees many dented billboards in outfield of Hershel Greer Stadium off of Bartolo's bat.
7. Helena Phantom der Nacht $15.4 million
Jose Infante
Mr. Infante was pleased to see Helena offer him a major league deal at the tender age of 18, almost assuring that he will never sent to the minors once he makes it to the big leagues. Pitching in AAA is not in this kids future as he is almost good enough to throw in the majors right now. Only time will tell, but he looks like he could be as good or better than the richer Jose Delgado. Infante sure can keep the ball down, has very good control, and has a scary 4 seamer. Lefthanded hitters will not look forward to seeing Infante, and it won't be a picnic for righties either. If this guy can improve his average slider, and I don't see why he won't, then he can be an elite set-up guy or closer. His lone weakness is a lack of velocity. Jose kept hitters to a .206 OAV, .283 OBP and rumour has it that he averaged 18 K9 in Cuba's top league despite topping out at 72 MPH on the radar gun. If the birth certificate is correct, Helena scored big time with this Cuban defector. Fidel has to surely be pissed about this one.
8. Charleston Cannons, $13.7 million
Ivan "The Terrible" Suarez
Not far behind Infante and Delgado is this 19 y/o Dominican. Suarez is good enough as I write this to pitch in the majors. Good splits, velocity, the ability to keep the ball down and a devastating 4 seamer are the keys to "Ivan the Terrible's" success. Charleston is taking a patient approach with Ivan. The Cannon's late signing
pitched in 2 regular season and 4 playoff games. He was 7 for 7 in save opportunities giving up 0 runs in 6.1 innings. If there is one thing to criticize about Ivan's game it is his lack of control. During the playoffs he plunked 2 guys, one of which charged half-way to the mound before realizing that the 6ft. 205 lb lefty might rearrange his face like a Picasso. Overall the Cannons are likely pleased to add this guy to their young corps.
9. Las Vegas Numa Numa, $13 million
Junior Molina
No stranger to spending significant money on IFAs, Xavier shelled out $13 million for Junior Molina SR., which should buy a lot of diapers for his young family. He and his wife Penelope have twins Esmeralda and Junior JR. The Numa Numa have to be pleased that their large investment has a young family as it might help keep this young man grounded while in Sin City. Molina possesses 2 very good pitches, a devastating 12-6 curveball and a slider with absolutely sick movement. He has shown an uncanny ability to throw those 2 pitches and his unpolished change-up and cutter with above average accuracy. Junior has good splits for a man of his age, but his velocity leaves a lot to be desired. At High A he had an impressive 110 strike outs a 1.29 WHIP, and a 6-6 record in 25 starts and 127.1 innings.
10. Philadelphia Pheremoniacs, $12.1
Louie "Armstrong" Valentin
Max made Louie "Armstrong" Valentin the second highest paid Cuban defector in Season 23. Valentin hails from Remedios, a hot bed for star ball players in Cuba's top league. "Armstrong" agonized over whether to or not to defect from the beautiful city in the Villa Clara province, fearing what might happen to his family. Like his fellow countryman Infante, Valentin has really good accuracy, unlike Infante, Louie can saw off a lot of bats with his 91 MPH heater. He had some growing pains at Low A, where he had a 5.05 ERA and a 1.41 WHIP. He gave up 14 homers while notching 97 K in 98 innings. Max would surely like to see this youngster learn how to keep the ball down a lot more and find away to put away the lefties. This multi-lingual hurler has a ridiculous change-up and a darn good 4 seam fastball. His slider might become good enough to show major league batters, though his forkball and curve likely won't become useful tools. This guy will almost surely make it to Philly as a long reliever. The 3rd highest paid IFA in Philly's history looks to be a good one folks.
11. Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns, $10.1 million
Melky Matos
Two good, possibly great in the future pitches, a 4 seamer and a slider. The 18 year old is a good groundball reliever with decent splits and excellent control. This late signee would do well to find a way to improve his velocity and ability to send lefthanded hitters back to the dugout with a frown. A gym rat, look for him to improve most aspects of his game.
12. Toronto Trout, $8.2 million
Javier Garza
This portly 18 year old has been asked to shed a few lbs by the Trout, scouts say they think he is onboard as they have seen his conditioning improve and they like his attitude and work ethic. A cousin of Cubs ace Matt, Javier had a tremendous first professional season at Low A. He has 3 good pitches and good splits. Needs to improve his control and would be better if he could find more velocity.
13. Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns, $8.1 million
Fautino Bastardo
Many GMs were displeased to see OKC pick-up this youngster, especially for this price. Good contact, plate vision, baserunning and power make this outfielder a good prospect. The main flaw of the Clowns slugger would be his splits which should hurt his average. In 377 ABs at Low A he maintained a .294 average while swatting 30 doubles, 28 Home Runs, and 105 RBI. One of the better bargains of Season 23.
14. Mexico City, $7.5 million
Shin-Soo Suzuki
This 24 year old from Japan threw at AA and 2 starts in the big leagues where he performed very well. A good value at $7.5 million, Suzuki has no real deficiencies. The 6 foot 2 inch 211 pound starting pitcher has shown an ability to keep the ball down, has good durability, stamina. He also has very good control, and great velocity to go with his serviceability splits and pitches.
15. Sioux Falls Screw Balls, $5.5 million
Carlos Sardinha
An above average defender as a corner outfielder with good contact. Possesses good speed and baserunning skills yet made no successful attempts at Low A last season. Good bang for the buck, should make an appearance in the big leagues one day.
16. (C) Montgomery Burns, $5 million
Alfredo Rosado
Good control, splits and 4 seamer despite poor velocity. Unfortunately his forkball, and curve generally show up at the plate looking like meatballs. His change may save him if he can improve it by another 15 points or more. A poor combination of durability and stamina will probably keep this fellow from becoming a regular on the 25 man roster Montgomery has a good major league staff and did well when they drafted 20 year old Chad Richard from nearby Homer Louisiana with 30th pick, so they are not fretting this forgettable signing.
17. Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns, $4.7 million
Victor Garza
OKC grabbed another 18 year old with good control and splits. His virtually non-existent velocity does not seem to diminish the effectiveness of his 4-seam fastball. He also has a substandard curve and forkball. Despite being a flyball pitcher, he managed to not allow any homeruns in Low A last season.
18. Chicago Crushers, $4.6 million
Wilkin Vazquez
This light throwing groundball inducing 18 year old has a good work ethic, good control and splits. He throws three pitches - a mean sinker, an average curve, and his change-up needs some work to be used effectively. He did manage a K per inning while splitting time at the Rookie and Low A levels. Arguably the best signing under $5 million.
19.Boston Red Sox, $4 million
Vic Aguilera
Vic is a 19 year old SS that is fast on the basepaths but lacks the skill to become a true base stealing threat at Fenway. Although he would be a good defender at the hot corner, his bat is severely lacking for that position. His range will never become good enough to become a major league SS or CF. His glove, arm strength and plate discipline must have been what convinced Mike45 to throw 4 bills at him
20. Toronto Trout,$3.6 million
Eli Gandarilla
An un-healthy dwarf with a passion for defence, the Trout may have found a bargain. Though not a threat with the stick, there are a lot of more useless hitters making money playing SS in the majors. Not an ideal bench player due to his lack of speed.
21. Florida Gators, $3.3 million
Joakim Rios
Florida went a slick defending pivot. A nice pick up for a NL team, especially for the price, Rios will be useful off the bench by utilizing his very good speed, baserunning and the ability to lay down a bunt for a base hit. He will put the ball in play a lot, it just won`t leave the infield unless there is an error on the play as he has a 0 rating for power.
22. Boston Red Sox, $3 million
Placido Morales
Rather then throw their prospect money away, Mike45 signed Morales. He will help out the minor league system.
23. Las Vegas Numa Numa, $ 2.8 million
Davey Bennett
As an 18 year old he projects to have excellent major league skills. Sadly for the Numa Numa, he will most likely never throw more than 30 innings in a season. A good value, nice to have on hand in the playoffs where Vegas often ends up after the regular season ends.
Honourable Mentions under $2.5 million go to:
Pat Sasaki
Carlos Santana
Don Tamura
Tony Candelaria
Delino Vincente
Josias Guerrero
Vic Cruz
Jair Alomar
Lorenzo Ayala
Jose Soriano
Mariano Ozuna
SEASON 23 DRAFT ANALYSIS
A.L. North
Ottawa Hosers
Choosing not to allocate much time or resources to scouting, the Hosers went into the draft fairly blind. They managed to land stocky right-hander Dwight Venafro with their top selection and he could become a solid pitcher down the road. Mixing up his repertoire with five pitches, Venafro needs to keep hitters off balance to succeed, as he doesn't have over-powering stuff. Time will tell if he'll find a rotation spot or settle into the bullpen, and his long-term value will likely depend on how he responds to his coaches. Not a wasted pick for Ottawa, but as their only “ray of hope” in this year’s draft, the Hosers will likely stay focused on guiding the pro team through another winning season.
Grade: C-
Sioux Falls Screw Balls
Waiting for them at pick #18 was one of the more intriguing players in the draft. Towering lefty Aramis Quixote tests off the charts in some areas, while demonstrating some serious control problems throughout his time at the University of Mississippi. His coaches rave about his conditioning and his ability to pitch to both lefties and righties when his command is working. "He could throw over 250 innings per season if he can stay focused and stop walking hitters!" There is some concern that his fastball won't be a major league calibre "out pitch" and some worries that he could have trouble with the long ball, especially when behind in the count. However, his potential is too great for the Screw Balls not to take a gamble at this stage in the first round. Quixote is a hard worker and will give them everything he's got in the tank - which is quite a bit. Sioux Falls heavily focused on pitching through most of this season's draft, and they came away with a few others who may develop into serviceable arms. If Trent Jay can develop a fastball, or if Thom Glaus or Ed Duffy can learn to pitch to righties they could find a role with "the 'Balls".
Grade: B
Syracuse Blue Sox
Speaking of a pitching-heavy draft approach, the Blue Sox selected pitchers with their first ten selections. Unfortunately, it appears that talented first-rounder Elvis Burks will stay in college leaving a gap at the top of the Syracuse draft board. Hard throwing lefty Ismael Vazquez has many tools to succeed, but doesn't seem to have the stuff to dominate at the pro level. He'll need to work his way through the system. 22 yr old Tony Guerra has a major league change-up, and is tough on left-handed hitters. He's started rookie ball as the team's closer, and could do well in that role if he doesn't get victimized by righties (especially when he reaches the higher levels). With their fourth selection, Andrew Snider might be the best draft value yet, with major league potential
that stems from his above average control and a stand-out curveball. He's been tagged as a fly ball pitcher, however, so long term success with rely on Snider keeping those inside the park.
Grade: B-
Toronto Trout
With the 23rd pick, the Trout chose reliever Henderson Buckley, one of the top few natural relief pitchers in this season's draft. Typically, a reliever's value is slightly lower due to the fact that he'll usually pitch fewer innings than a good starter, so determining exactly when to spend a pick on relief is a point of strategy. Buckley was certainly one of the best pitchers available when Toronto came to pick, and they feel that they've landed an integral part of their future bullpen. A notoriously slow worker, Buckley takes his time walking on and off the field; inches around the mound getting comfortable and takes his time between pitches. As slow-moving as he can be, his pitches are anything but slow, showing an impressive five-pitch repertoire with serious zip and control to keep hitters off balance. Buckley can keep his sinker fast and low to induce ground ball outs, and barring some “delay-of-game” warnings from umpires he should shine when he arrives in Toronto.
Grade: B+
A.L. East
Boston Red Sox
Lanky 18 year old lefty Geraldo Cruz is known for keeping the ball low and achieving ground ball outs. This is an appealing skill in a park like Fenway, where the Redsox would like to see their 6th overall pick join the rotation a few seasons down the road. Cruz has the unlikely combination of low velocity and control trouble, but he should be able to overcome those issues to be a solid major leaguer. He's the only prize asset for Boston in this season's draft, and at #6 overall, while he looks pretty darn good - it's certainly not a slam dunk pick.
Grade: C
Durham County Ramblers
the #3 overall pick was spent on J.P. Dixon, probably the best power hitter among this season's crop. Without a doubt best suited as a DH, Dixon's potential fielding embarrassments will be far overshadowed by his prowess as a slugger that will fit nicely in the Durham Athletic Park. Dixon is going to be a fearsome home run threat once he matures into a pro, and if he can also hit for average he'll grab some serious headlines. 2nd rounder Bret Mordecai is a decent outfielder who could have a role for the Ramblers if he improves his batting eye, while 3rd rounder Ralph Simmons is a versatile fielder with great power who could do some damage for Durham if he can even slightly learn to hit righties.
Grade: A
Jacksonville Sunbirds
With second bagger Johnny Seay joining Dixon in the A.L. East, it promises to be a tough division for flyball-prone pitchers in the years to come! The rangy second baseman is a good athlete with decent wheels and natural power. He has the potential to be an impact player for Jacksonville if they can keep him focused and on track. The main criticism of Seay is his affinity for the nightlife and lack of interest in maintaining an off-field training program. He doesn’t learn about opposing pitchers’ tendencies or work on subtle nuances that could take the talented 22 yr old to the next level. The Sunbirds are hoping that he makes it to AA without being checked into AA, and if he stays on track he could easily become a regular on the home run leader list. The signings of Norm Hutton and Ed Towers put the next Jax draft choice in the 4th round, where they took outfielder Claude Gabriel, who despite home run power will have a tough road to make the pro club.
Grade: B
New York Crunch
This season the Crunch had five picks in the top hundred and chose five hitters with those picks. Their top selection was 21 year old Boone “Bulldog” Dixon, a tenacious infielder who despite being drafted as a shortstop might be better suited at third. At 5’7” the University of Mississippi junior has classic “small dog” syndrome, and one would guess that Dixon sees himself as 6’5” 230. There is no quit in the bulldog, as his efforts on the field can exceed his skill level at times. He has decent power for his stature, and should be a sound defender when he settles into a position. The second “Dixon” in this year’s draft (his younger brother is Durham slugger J.P.) will need work a little harder to grind out a niche as a pro. Max Vasquez, Bernard Adams, Marshall Lowry and Steve Hudson are all quality draft choices: players with some value, but none is a lock for success. Vasquez is a decent fielder who struggles against righties, Adams struggles in the field but has offensive potential (except against lefties), Lowry is a poorer version of Adams (but can’t hit righties instead of lefties), and Hudson’s redeeming quality is his power, though he’s a long-shot to retain anything more than fleeting value. If Dixon and one other become ML regulars (Adams is the most likely) then the Crunch will have squeezed the most value out of their picks.
Grade: B-
A.L. South
Charlotte Designated Drinkers
Few teams can sit back after draft day and feel as confident in the value of their picks as the DD's. Choosing 19th, Charlotte was pleased to see second bagger Stephen Butler still on the board. Butler is a complete ballplayer, offering a great blend of athleticism and baseball intelligence. He has decent power for his small stature, great plate discipline and a high compete level. Time will tell if Butler has the range to be effective at second, but he's demonstrated slick glove-work and should improve as he goes. Many considered him a top ten pick going into draft day, so Charlotte did quite well in round one. Their subsequent picks were as good or better, as starting pitcher Russ Rusch and slugger Jimmy Romano both look like legit draft day steals! Rusch is an 18 year old southpaw with a craftiness that makes up for the lack of blast on his heater. He's very tough on lefthanded hitters, and if he can put righties away with consistency, he should be a solid #1 or #2 starter. Romano is a California boy with a potential all-star bat if he continues on his current trajectory. He has a little trouble with lefties, but his power presence in the heart of the batting order will make him very hard to platoon. His make-up at first base is awkwardly adequate, so there's a chance that a DH role could help him focus on being an offensive leader. Even 80th overall pick Renyel Estrada could become a useful piece of the pitching staff if he gets his control problems figured out. Charlotte did very well this time around, obtaining great value with the picks they had.
Grade: A+
Florida GATORs
Scouts have been watching shortstop Anthony Green since he starred in the little league world series, and he's continued to represent his age group at the national level as one of the slickest up and coming shortstops in the country. His mastery of his position is impressive to be sure, and his professionalism and sportsmanship are without question, but his stock has fallen slightly in the past year or two. At one time Green was seen as an automatic first overall pick, but his ability as a hitter to adjust to major league pitching has come into question. He has a great sense of the strike zone and is an excellent contact hitter, but the former prodigy might not have the build or upper body strength to be a consistent threat at the pro level. The GATORs couldn't pass on Green as he slipped to them in the 8 spot, and time will tell if he can prove doubters wrong about his long term offensive value. Nonetheless, Florida has drafted a marketable and polished shortstop for their future. With pitcher Kendry Martin on the bubble in regard to his effectiveness and worth as a big league starter, the hopes for Green are quite high with management.
Grade: B+
Louisville Lobsters
Before entering into a conversation about the Lobsters’ draft results, we must discuss the Ezeqiuel Manzanillo signing. The 18 year old Dominican shortstop is the real deal, and he’ll be a regular in the Louisville lineup before long. The signing took a great deal of financial resources from other facets of the team’s developmental budget, making them unable to come to terms with their top choice Greg Scott. Scott, another shortstop, might also have taken exception to the 28 million dollar bonus the club gave Manzanillo. Either way, the Lobsters will move on without Scott and need to be happy with their second choice in the draft, lefthander Kirk Taylor who they took four picks after Scott. Fundamentally sound in all areas, Taylor projects as a big part of the future bullpen. Potentially a closer, or at least a pitcher who doesn’t shy away from high pressure situations, Louisville is elated to land a significant pitcher to go along with their International prize.
Grade: B+
Nashville Catfish
Choosing 7th overall, Nashville opted for Vincente Hernandez, an 18 year old center fielder from the Bronx. A patient, healthy, contact hitter, Hernandez displays good instincts in the outfield and despite lacking enough home run power to make him a star slugger, he has a natural blend of speed and athleticism that should make him a solid pro down the road. The Catfish then chose four more players who could prove to be decent value from their position. Not able to handle great defensive responsibilities, outfielder Joel Roth looks to have the power that Hernandez lacks, and if he can round out the rest of his offensive skill set he should provide some punch to the lineup. Pitchers Dustin Worley, Joe Cooke and Quilvio James all look like potential big league starters. Cooke and James have a few more question marks, but Worley looks like he could be a very solid addition.
Grade: A
A.L. West
Las Vegas Numa Numa
Signing Boots Cash, Pedro Rojas and Jesus Astacio meant that Vegas had little chance to make waves with this season’s draft. They did wind up with three supplemental picks (between 43-56), and of those choices, catcher Rolando Silva is worth mentioning. Scouts who saw him play at the University of Miami were quick to notice Silva’s great ability to draw the base on balls. He protects the plate well, does well in clutch situations and hit over .400 against lefties over his four years for the Hurricanes. The questions about Silva are about his ability to be a regular catcher at the pro level. His defense is adequate at best and there have been suggestions that he would do better in a different role – but if he makes his bat indispensable, the Numa Numa will find a way to get him to the plate.
Grade: C+
Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns
Without much hype around this season’s draft class, the Clowns beat writers have found cause to focus on awkward 18 year old Delino Owen. If nothing else, Owen has fantastic speed which will he struts in the field as well as on the bases. OKC would love to see Owen turn into an important part of their offence, but he really needs to fine tune his approach at the plate to become a high OBP table-setter atop the lineup. He’ll never have great power, so he’ll need to learn to hit consistent line drives and learn to be more selective with his swings. Also inconsistent with his glove-work at second base, Owen will see his value drop if he needs to move to an easier position. Fortunately, he has plenty of time to develop and at this point he’s worth keeping an eye on.
Grade: C
Salem Sanguillens
The Sanguillens came away from the draft with a few head scratchers. Top selection was Bubbles McGraw at #15 and it might appear that there was a bit of a premium because the man’s name is “Bubbles”. He’s a tiny guy with a fantastic glove at shortstop, a unique personality in the locker room and some decent baseball skills in general. His offensive upside, however, does seem a bit limited for a first round pick, and without game-breaking speed he seems one-faceted. Salem then chose three catchers among their next four picks, none of whom will challenge current rookie Wilfredo Martinez behind the plate, or AA catching prospect Reagan Beaulac for his offense. In general, the Sanguillens are already looking forward to next season’s draft.
Grade: D
Scottsdale Fighting Chokes
With the number four overall choice in the draft, Scottsdale played it reasonably safe and chose shortstop Ryan Wright. They didn’t land a future superstar, but Wright should have a steady career as a good hitter who can play responsibly at short or move to other positions if the need arises. Wright should be a very good everyday player, as he really has no glaring flaws in his game aside from a few nagging injuries that the Chokes hope are in his past. Pitcher Bert Kerr and utility man Mark Chang both stand a chance to carve out a role if they develop well.
Grade: B
N.L. North
Chicago Crushers
With yet another high first round choice, the Crushers continue to focus on pitching, selecting stocky 22 year old righty Don Creek. Creek was certainly at the top of many draft boards, with the only red flags arising from the potential for a tired arm. He’s cleanly the most consistent and talented pitcher across the board, with great control, movement and power in his repertoire. Creek is going to be a very, very good pitcher in this league, the only question is whether he has the innings in him to be a starter and whether he can stay healthy. Obviously his value is exponentially higher as a healthy starter than as an injury prone bullpen jockey. If he can throw 7 innings every five days, the Crushers are going to be winning a lot more games a few seasons from now.
Grade: A
Detroit Tiger Sharks
With Josh Baker as their top draft choice, the Tiger Sharks didn’t really take a player who will be a leader for their franchise. Baker is a quiet player on and off the field, giving them a serious second baseman, a spray hitter with some speed and enough gamesmanship to compete hard every day. Baker looks like a quality player, though maybe he was taken ten picks too early. Detroit’s next few picks look like better value for their draft positions, as Graeme Huskey has a great sinker and should be a steady pitcher in the mid-late innings; Neil Redman is a gem of a defensive shortstop, albeit very light- hitting; and slugger “Big Vic” Domingo has crazy major league power if he can learn to hit a little bit smarter. At the end of the day, some interesting bits for the motor city.
Grade: B
Montreal Maroons
The Maroons threw everything they had at scintillating Dominican closer
Eliezer Perez. Perez will be a good pitcher for Montreal in a couple of seasons. The same can’t be said for any of their draft picks, most of whom will grow up to be lawyers and teachers and salesmen and such.
Grade: F
Philadelphia Pheremoniacs
Without a pick until #57, Philly didn’t have high expectations this time around. They were fairly smart with how they used these “secondary” selections and for the most part converted them into something reasonably useful. Esteban Guerrero is a fantastic defender at second base and despite being a bit pedestrian at the dish, might hit lefties well enough to platoon (or at least have decent value off the bench). Charlie Purcell is a hard working relief pitcher who likely already has the stuff to succeed at AAA. If he’s able to take it up a slight notch in the next few seasons, he could find himself with a major league audition. Herm “Sobie” Sobolewski might have the paunch and ‘stache of a seventies detective, but he actually looks to be an above average major league hitter if he can quit smoking colts and his knees let him keep catching. The Pheremoniacs did as well as could be expected with a limited hand in this season’s draft
Grade: B
N.L. East
Baltimore Barons
At pick #25, the Barons were pretty happy to find Jordan Keppel still available. A steady pitcher with a low 90’s fastball, Keppel frequently finds the strike zone and can make hitters miss when he mixes things up. He projects to be at least a mid rotation starter for the Barons, with no real red flags except perhaps that sometimes when he gets hit, he gets hit hard. He should be a good compliment to Mel Darr and Maicer Calles in the Baltimore rotation.
Grade: B+
Cincinnati Red Army
With two picks in the top 30, the Red Army opted to focus on pitching and landed towering 6’5” 18 year old righty Joe Hissey as well as medium-sized southpaw Mark Zhang. Hissey looks like the real deal, though he’s a bit raw and will likely take at least three or four years to develop through the Cincinnati system. Hissey needs to improve against left-handed hitters and would do well to figure out how to induce a few more ground balls. Zhang has a deadly low sinker and a good curve, and frequently surprises radar guns and opposing hitters alike with his varied arsenal and pitching IQ. Zhang needs to throw hard to be successful, but sometimes this results in wildness and he’ll need to avoid meltdowns if he’s to succeed at the major league level. Both pitchers represent good value for their draft slot.
Grade:A
New York New Jerseys
In the twelve slot, the NYNJ’s opted for community college slugger Richie Knight. Knight is only 5’8” but has a strong and compact build, a swift home run swing and a good overall hitter’s mentality. He’s able to make adjustments the second time he sees a pitcher, and is always learning and figuring out ways to improve. He should hit an effortless .280-20-80 and could potentially improve on that in the right environment. The downside to Knight is his defense. While he doesn’t have poor foot-speed, his reaction time to balls-in-play could be problematic in the outfield – it might be safer to get him used to first base.
Grade: B
Atlanta Spartans
With the #29 pick, the Spartans chose slick defensive centerfielder Sparky Wilson. Some scouts don’t like Wilson’s offensive upside, as despite his decent speed and 10-15 home-run potential, he likely won’t be able hit for decent average. His natural defensive ability might make it worth it for Atlanta to find room for him at the bottom of the order. Pitcher Jeff Anderson and shortstop Heinie Leyritz will both struggle to succeed as they ascend towards the pro ranks. A forgettable draft year for the successful franchise.
Grade: D+
N.L. South
Charleston Cannons
Outfielder Ezdra Paredes will strike out a ton. He can’t lay down a bunt to save his life. He’ll also drop a few balls in the outfield. These are likely the reasons that kept Paredes from being a consensus top ten pick, and saw him slip to the Cannons in slot #17. With a good outfield arm and tons of natural hitting ability, Paredes will have a good chance to make a few teams regret passing him over. Though he can hit for power, it isn’t his main offensive strength. Paredes drives the ball well to all fields and can earn a few free passes as well. He’ll need good coaching to reach his maximum potential, but Charleston should be pleased with their first rounder. Relief pitcher Trey Sappelt is a project, but he should flirt with major league success of some sort. Shortstop Wes Weaver can’t really hit, but he’s a special defensive player. The Cannons have some new pieces to work with .
Grade: A-
Mexico City Jalapenos
With six picks in the top 60, the Jalapenos had a chance to add some good youth in this draft. Their top two selections were outfielders, Dusty Rigby and Chad Hernandez. Rigby could be the more well-rounded athlete, bringing some speed, defense and a decent bat, but Hernandez is the better pure hitter of the two. While Rigby has no glaring weaknesses, he doesn’t have star potential and will need to clearly define a role for himself to be successful. Hernandez is small and slow, but he’s an above average contact hitter with surprising power and a strong outfield arm. Both players are worth watching as they progress through the M.C. farm system. Catcher Chili Evans has moderate pop in his bat, but his skill behind the plate is lacking. Groundball pitcher Dan Corder could turn into a good mid-rotation workhorse and possibly better. Shortstop Harry Kaye is a good defender with a fantastic arm, and though he’s light-hitting he shouldn’t embarrass himself at the plate. Overall, a solid showing for the Jalapenos.
Grade: B
Montgomery Burns
Not selecting until pick #30, the Burns were pleased with 20 year old sinker-forkballer Chad Richard, a patient righty with decent control and a five pitch arsenal. Richard has a much better success rate against right-handed hitting, and he could be pressed into bullpen work if he’s not able to pitch six innings every fifth game. Scouts project him to gain another 15 pounds by the time he’s major league ready. Second rounder Louis Redding has great control of his fastball-curveball combo, but despite throwing at a very limited velocity he doesn’t have the stamina to face more than a couple of batters before hitting the showers. He could be an effective role player in the Montgomery bullpen if they have the depth to roster a pitcher who can’t give them many innings. Third rounder Willie Villa could be another long term bullpen option for the Burns in a draft that could have gone better or worse.
Grade: C
San Antonio Banderas es Zorro
The only significant selection for San Antonio this time around was a big one: the #1 overall pick, Steven Soriano out of CCU. Soriano is possibly the most ML-ready player in the draft, showing a great contact bat and the ability to work deep into counts and drive the ball to all fields. The only questions about Soriano’s future might be whether his range will be good enough to stick with his familiar second base position or if he’d be better suited somewhere else. He’s a lock to be a star player in San Antonio, and he gives them not only a marketable face for the fans to get excited about, but also a leader on and off the field. If he can learn better plate discipline, he should be a force to be reckoned with.
Grade: A
N.L. West
Helena Phantom der Nacht
For Helena, taking infielder Al Barber is a bit of a head-scratcher, as the Phantom infield is sewn up quite tightly with great young talent already. Barber brings versatility in the field, as he can play a number of positions. His defense in adequate, but not outstanding, so maybe he’s suited for a utility role? There’s some power in his bat, though he doesn’t have the complete offensive pedigree necessary to be a hitting star. His contact and batting eye could both use some work, but Helena could have done worse at #28.
Grade: C-
L.A. Dead Bunnies
For anyone who didn’t think that Don Creek was the best pitcher in the draft, Kane Neill was likely their choice. The Dead Bunnies have acquired a great young 20 year old lefty who hasn’t even finished growing yet! Boasting five good pitches and pinpoint accuracy, Neill held left-handed college hitters to a paltry .125 batting average. His ultimate success will be determined by the righties, and if he can hit the strike zone with the consistency that he’s capable of, L.A. should have a great work-horse to round out their young rotation. They’re hoping that Neill will be able to throw well over 200 innings per year in his prime.
Grade: A+
San Fransisco Streets
With Murray Posey at #5 in the draft, the Streets have found themselves a great hitter and solid fielder. Posey can play second, but might be better suited at third. He has major league ready power and should develop into a fearsome heart-of-the-order hitter. The strikeouts will be there, but they’ll be countered by his run production. It will be tempting to rush Posey through the system, but the SF brass should be careful to coax the maximum potential out of their newest prospect.
Grade: A
Vancouver Vampire Bats
At pick #21, the V-Bats opted for speedy defensive centerfielder Horacio Valbuena. Despite his lightning legs and gold glove potential, the Vancouver scouts had thought Horacio to have better offensive potential than they now realize. He’ll need to get on base in order to use his world-class “jets” and it remains to be seen if he has that in him. Second selection Elvis Pedersen could help the team as a depth starter or long relief man, but generally not much to look forward to out of this Vancouver crop.
Grade: C-
SEASON 22 DRAFT SYNOPSIS
DRAFT ANALYSIS
A.L. North
Ottawa Hosers
Center fielder Wilton Benes is a defense-first athlete who projects to be a part time player at best. The Hosers like his intangibles, such as bunting and baserunning and see him down the road as a fifth outfielder who can pinch hit vs lefties. Catcher Giovanni Pelfrey is a capable defensive catcher, but with limited bat-skill he’ll never likely reach the professional level. Pelfrey looks to be an asset handling young pitchers through the Hosers minor league system. A forgettable draft for Ottawa this time around.
Grade: D-
Syracuse Blue Sox
With the 9th pick in this season’s draft, the Blue Sox were happy to see talented Kimera Rhodes fall to them. Rhodes could have been a top 3 pick if he didn’t come with some health concerns, making him a high risk-high reward selection for Syracuse. A solid all-around player, Rhodes can hit for both power and average, while boasting decent speed and a strong arm. Outfielder Luis Noesi shows some promise as a solid hitter with great speed. A criticism of the lefty-hitting Noesi is in the field, where his weak glove-work could make him a liability in left or right. Defensively more of a first-baseman, Noesi probably doesn’t have the offensive impact that most teams look for from first. Pitcher Steve Becker shows some promise with a great fastball and pin-point control. He projects to be a solid late-inning arm for the Sox.
Grade: A
Toronto Trout
With pick #20, the Trout selected shortstop Raymond Miller, an excellent defender who likely won’t boast the offensive chops needed to make waves as a pro. Miller has blazing speed and good instincts, which should get him as far as one can get without being a threat at the plate. He has a history of hamstring problems, so Toronto will need to keep the training/medical staff on their toes.
Grade: C-
Trenton Terror Hawks
Pitcher Nick Austin could prove to be a steal for the Terror Hawks. While he won’t blow away any radar guns, Austin has excellent stuff and looks like a top of the rotation starter if the 18 yr old develops well through the Trenton minor league system. They’ll need to monitor his inning-count going forward, but he represents excellent potential. Outfielder Rey Sheldon has some great raw skills, but his work ethic might need to evolve if he’s to be a contributor. If Sheldon stays in shape and avoids trouble away from the ballpark, he could mature into a solid center fielder, a good contact hitter and an offensive sparkplug.
Grade: A-
A.L. East
Boston Red Sox
The Red Sox admittedly didn’t exercise due diligence in this season’s draft prep, and the selection of “Wild” Juan Olmedo demonstrates this. Olmedo is a strange animal: the shocking velocity on his knuckleball is something hard to grasp, however, he has tons of trouble finding the strike zone and doesn’t look likely to improve in this regard. Boston could certainly have used this pick more wisely. The selection of left fielder Lou McQuillan is a safe one, as the steady outfielder has a potential major league bat. He has trouble in the field and he’ll never be a star, but with some hard work McQuillan could turn into a lunchbox-style pro player. Catcher Bill Sosa can handle himself adequately behind the dish and also brings some hitting ability, however, neither Sosa or McQuillan will likely be at the heart of the Sox rebuilding efforts.
Grade: D+
Durham County Ramblers
With pick #15, Durham had to be pleased to land righty Raymond James. The 20 year old James looks like a workhorse, and though he might serve up a few fly balls in the home run park, his core attributes are sensational. A knock on James might be that he only has a three pitch arsenal, including a fairly mediocre forkball. To be really successful, his fastball and curve will need to be coached into serious “big league” caliber pitches. The Ramblers followed the James selection with three hitters who won’t be oft lauded for defense. Timo Conroy is a durable contact hitter whose strength is hitting lefties. Cecil Brennaman and Joakim Johnson are patient sluggers who could be successful as major league power threats if they can also hit for a reasonable batting average.
Grade: B+
Jacksonville Sunbirds
The Sunbirds chose highly touted outfielder Dan Burke with the 8th pick in the draft and he’s the real deal. Burke, who some scouts felt could have gone a few spots higher, is a prototypical leadoff man. Boasting fantastic speed and great instincts, the athletic Burke hits lefties well and even has some surprising power. The only knock on Burke is his defense, which although adequate for a left-fielder, raises questions about how someone with such great speed can have such an ordinary range in the field. Jacksonville followed up with two pitchers, Jimmy Giambi and Nick Lowery. Lowery has some promise, but will really need all the help he can get to progress to a high level. Giambi is only 5’8” - almost unheard of for a pitcher, but he could prove useful out of the bullpen if his forkball gets a little better.
Grade: B
New York Crunch
Due to their off-season free agent acquisitions, the Crunch only had two selections in the top five rounds. With the 14th pick, they did well to draft Domingo Acosta, who has drawn comparisons to Dan Burke in terms of his speed, leadoff abilities and lack of fielding acumen. Acosta has the makings of a very intelligent hitter, with great plate patience and the ability to drive the ball to all fields. Acosta has elected to bypass his senior year at Southern Illinois to start his baseball career as a 21 year old. The Crunch also chose smallish second baseman Hal Ryan, also very fleet of foot with fair hitting ability. Ryan will need to find a way to cut down on the mistakes in all areas of his game, as he’s prone to base-running blunders, as well as poor glove work by middle-infielder standards. He’ll need to work his tail off for an opportunity, as he doesn’t have nearly as much talent as Acosta.
Grade: B
A.L. South
Charlotte Designated Drinkers
The Drinkers consider themselves quite fortunate to land towering righty Pedro Martin with the 22nd pick. Martin is a strong kid, who could turn into a top-tier starter capable of throwing well over 200 innings per year. Without a serious “go to” pitch and a tendency towards fly balls, Martin will need to rely on his excellent control and four developing pitches to outsmart hitters instead of overpowering them. Only 18 years old, scouts will no doubt be monitoring his rise through the Charlotte system. First baseman Al Dunston is a safe pick, but doesn’t have the star offensive potential that many like to see from first base. Third round southpaw Dwight Weaver throws a crafty fastball-forkball mix that gives left-handed hitters trouble. He could be a long term option for the D.D’s bullpen.
Grade: A-
Florida GATORs
The Gators opted for long-term projects with their high draft picks, taking 18 year olds with their first three choices. First rounder Mark Lawton is exceptionally quick, both on the bases and covering territory at shortstop. Lawton has a much easier time hitting lefties, and will need to make seriously significant strides to become a relevant offensive player. In the field, he has a strong arm and will only need to cut down on mistakes to be effective. Alex Sweeney and Gabe McEnroe are both close to being at a pro level defensively, while likely never offering more than fleeting success at the plate. Not a winning draft for Florida in terms of building blocks for the franchise.
Grade: D
Louisville Lobsters
With the 21st pick the Lobsters chose pitcher Mark Quinn, an undersized left-handed pitcher with good control and a decent arsenal of pitches. Quinn has yet to sign in Louisville and has expressed a preference for football over baseball. It looks like the Lobsters will need to settle for a compensation pick next season. Beyond the first round, Louisville has nothing to be thrilled about with 5’9” pitcher Bryce Flores struggling with his control and outfielders Enrique Blanco and Rick Rehfield looking like long-shots for anything more than fleeting success. The Lobsters didn’t take a player over six feet tall until the fifth round!
Grade: C-
Nashville Catfish
Despite what appears to be a very meticulous draft plan, the Catfish may regret their first round selection of pitcher Brad Burks. Renowned for his patience, Burks has five average pitches but doesn’t really excel in any areas. Just out of high school, he’ll need to show serious signs of improvement if he’s going to be more than just another pretty arm. Nashville also selected a duo of catchers, including the highly-touted Puerto Rican Junior Pelaez and the more limited Dwight Johnstone. Pelaez was the top catcher in the draft according to some scouts, as he boasts a rifle arm and sound fundamentals behind the plate to go along with a dangerous bat. With great plate patience and home run potential, Pelaez might struggle with his batting average as he has a tough time adjusting to inside pitches from righties. If he stays healthy, Pelaez has a very high ceiling. If he doesn’t stay healthy, then at least they have Dwight Johnstone. Johnstone is decent behind the plate and can hit well enough to stay in the lineup. Not being able to withstand the rigors of a full season, he’s ideally suited for backup work (which is his preference). The Catfish took 3rd baseman Daniel Wise in the 4th round and he’s a bonafide slugger and strikeout aficionado who will never hit for average but projects to a 30 HR guy at minimum. The qualities of second rounder, pitcher Calvin Punto are unknown. The ‘fish are keeping Punto’s identity close to the vest.
Grade: B
A.L. West
Las Vegas Numa Numa
Consistently adept at finding skilled talent despite mediocre drafting position, Vegas once again obtained a nice asset with their top choice Charlie Torres. A great contact hitter with moderate power and deceptive speed, Torres is a good clubhouse guy who should bring a stable if unspectacular presence to the Numa Numa. Torres’ weaknesses focus around his hand-eye coordination, as is demonstrated by his poor throwing arm and his embarrassing inability to lay down a bunt. Infielders Lazy Albers and Alex Ordaz are lunchbox guys who could wind up filling some useful bench roles, and in the case of Albers a potentially versatile fielding specialist. Hard-throwing pitcher Rick Franklin shows some flashes of promise, but will have a hard time getting very far unless his fastball vastly improves.
Grade: B
Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns
The Clowns’ scouts almost entirely steer clear of colleges in favor of spending their time hanging around high schools instead. The club only took one player over 18 amongst their first fifteen picks and 20/25 picks were 18 year olds. With three picks in the top 40, the Clowns selected two pitchers and a left fielder – all youngsters with some time to improve. Clarence Shuck is a pure “location pitcher” with five options in his arsenal. His rise through the system will determine whether he has the stamina to join the rotation and whether the “fly-ball” hurler has the craftiness to make outs at the top level. Raul Gabriel is a short reliever by pedigree and should be able to pitch almost every day. He was among Central Scouting’s top-rated relievers in this season’s draft and looks like a great value at pick 28. Gabriel doesn’t have high 90’s stuff, but his fastball has tons of movement and is a serious “out pitch”. Left fielder Santos Mercedes is the cousin of all-world slugger Alfonso, but he doesn’t have the family power or likely enough to win a starting job. He’s a low-ceiling flier pick who will need some serious coaching to turn the corner.
Grade: B-
Salem Sanguillens
With the #10 pick in the draft, Salem chose outfielder Walt O’Neill. A hitter with major league upside and good athletic ability, O’Neill isn’t flashy and won’t likely be a star. Not blessed with great speed, and only displaying moderate power, the teenager from Ohio is a guy who knows how to get on base and comes ready to play every day. O’Neill’s defense doesn’t have a wow factor, so he’ll need to be a steady clutch hitter and take advantage of his opportunities. He’s projected to reach 90/18/75/.285 levels if he’s in a solid lineup. Other Sanguillen choices of note are 5’9” pitcher Stu Nixon who will need to overcome problems with control and fly balls, and 5’5” infielder Joey Evans who looks like a utility defensive backup with limited offensive potential.
Grade: C+
Scottsdale Fighting Chokes
The Chokes took one of the top starting pitchers in this season’s draft class. Towering 6’7” Japanese-American Ozzie Tamura has serious potential if he can stay healthy. A workhorse-style starter, Tamura has already had two shoulder surgeries by age 18 and his awkward delivery makes him a risk for further complications. If he’s careful with his valuable arm, Tamura shows three ML caliber pitches and impressive poise and control. He’ll need to work on keeping the ball down in the strike zone, but he should be a front end starter for Scottsdale. 33rd pick Julio Tarasco also has some promise, and though he isn’t overpowering he doesn’t have any glaring weakness either. He might wind up in the bullpen if he doesn’t build his stamina.
Grade: B+
N.L. North
Chicago Crushers
With the second overall pick this time around, Chicago continued with their focus on acquiring front end starting pitching and selected 21 year old southpaw Jerome Johnson. With perhaps the best slider some scouts have encountered, Johnson is close to “can’t miss” with brilliant command and a well-developed arsenal to keep hitters off-balance. “JJ” is especially tough vs left-handed batters and how he develops against righties will determine whether he’ll be good or great. The Crushers also selected shortstop Vic Wainwright, he of slick glove and strong arm who may benefit with a move to third base down the road. Wainwright shows good bat contact, moderate power and should be able to contribute offense at a ML level. Hard throwing Regan Flaherty has a brilliant fastball and looks to have potential for improvement, though his durability issues may force him to the bullpen. There are some concerns about Flaherty’s control, but if he can overcome those issues he could be a useful piece.
Grade: A
Detroit Tiger Sharks
Lefty Louie Pujols is hard to evaluate. On one hand, his location is deadly accurate and he can surprise the radar gun and hitters with the combination of velocity and movement on his pitches. On the other, Pujols can be stubborn with his pitch selection and might rely too heavily on a slider that hitters can make adjustments for. He also has a tendency to leave hittable pitches out over the plate for right-handed hitters to feast on. Only 18, Pujols is still quite raw and if he can develop better consistency and avoid shoulder trouble he could turn into a prized asset for the Tiger Sharks. Detroit’s subsequent selections (pitcher Barry Lanier; second bagger Bryce Dodson; center fielder Jair Bennett) all have some winning attributes, but at the end of the day aren’t complete major league players.
Grade: B
Montreal Maroons
The Maroons haven’t been allocating money for amateur scouting in quite some time. This is reflected in their lack of any promising talent in this season’s amateur draft. Supplemental picks Sherman Wise (p), Robinzon Lee (2b) and Steve Hill (ss) most likely represent a AAA ceiling. Montreal continues to focus on recruiting international talent, meaning that newly inked phenomenal Mexican phenom Felipe Lee is more than an adequate reason to be satisfied with a poor drafting grade.
Grade: F
Philadelphia Pheremoniacs
The lower the pick in the first round, the greater the risk of missing the mark. With pick #23, Philly went as low risk as possible, taking stocky relief man Stephen Saunders. Scouts say the 19 year old community college student from Michigan is a great teammate and strong leader with fairly dependable arsenal well suited for late-inning success as a major leaguer. Saunders is the only selection of note this season for Philly, but it’s certainly not a wasted choice.
Grade: B
N.L. East
Baltimore Barons
Felix Ross has been compared on several occasions to former major leaguer Ozzie Smith. The Baron’s #3 overall selection is a wizard in his own right, extremely agile and light on his feet with a surprising arm – powerful and accurate from shallow left field, Ross is excellent throwing across his body while moving to his right. Not known for his offense, Ross brings intelligence to the plate. Patient, with good hand-eye coordination he’s a decent contact hitter but doesn’t have the strength to consistently drive the ball with much power. The Barons will be thrilled if their future gold glove candidate is good for a .270 average with 10-12 home runs per season.
Grade: B+
Cincinnati Red Army
With their first choice at #11, the Red Army was happy to see shortstop Chico Villafuerte still on the board. In the conversation with Gene Gold and Felix Ross as the top shortstops in this season’s draft, Villafuerte is still a raw commodity. Blessed with eye-popping speed on the bases and a howitzer for an arm, Cincy’s top choice will need to learn better plate patience and improve his glove work. A lock to be a major leaguer down the road, some scouts see Villafuerte as a third baseman whose overall value depends on how he develops as a hitter. With pick #51, the Army chose pitcher Archie Camilli, a steal at his draft position and a potential mid rotation ML starter. A hard worker with excellent control, the 18 year old has developed a knuckleball as the key feature of his varied arsenal. He’s a smart pitcher with a decent future. Cincinatti should be reasonably happy with their draft value this season.
Grade:A
New York New Jerseys
The N.Y.N.J.’s have landed themselves a couple of solid defensive assets in center fielder Bronson Cishek and corner man Joaquin Gonzales. Many scouts consider Cishek to be the best center fielder available in this year’s crop. He’s a natural at getting a great read on initial contact and the result is that Cishek covers a large portion of the outfield, often taking pressure off his corner-outfield teammates. Not know as an offensive threat, the left-handed Cishek can contribute decently against right handed pitching and his ultimate value in the batter’s box will be determined by how coachable the 18 year old is as he matures. Gonzales is a solid, but unspectacular player with a strong throwing arm who can play several positions well. He makes decent contact at the plate, but doesn’t project to make an offensive impact at the pro level. Neither player should be an integral part of the success or failure of the franchise. All things considered, not the most impactful draft for New York.
Grade: C
Washington Swamp Cats
Coming off a stellar 106-win season, the Swamp Cats were dealing with poor draft position and didn’t have high hopes. Selecting 6’5” high school pitcher Junior Garvin is a solid move for the Cats. Boasting five pitches, a strong arm and generally decent stuff, Garvin’s Achilles heel is his erratic control, which could hinder his reliability but shouldn’t prevent him from being an effective major league pitcher. Not a bad value at the 31st pick of the draft.
Grade: B
N.L. South
Charleston Cannons
With the top overall selection in this season’s draft, the Cannons didn’t hesitate to select shortstop Gene Gold. While many scouts consider Gold to be the best “all around” player in the draft, he doesn’t blow away the field in any area. A good athlete, Gold has some speed, is a solid hitter and represents himself well in the field. However, for a #1 overall shortstop pick, Gold doesn’t approach Ross in the field, nor does he have the raw speed and cannon arm of Villafuerte, but the Cannons hope that when they look back on the draft they’ve chosen the shortstop who can make the greatest offensive impact. The Cannons also chose location-challenged curveball specialist Alberto Quevedo, who might struggle to blow away major league hitting.
Grade: A-
El Paso Blancos
The Blancos’ only significant selection this time around was #6 pick, southpaw hurler Charlie Moore. A very motivated potential top of the rotation starter, Moore has a good fastball, a high compete level and no glaring weaknesses. For a pitcher of his potential to reach his ceiling, El Paso will need to handle his workload carefully and hope that he can eventually be able to routinely throw 200+ innings per season. To nit-pick a potential weakness from Moore would be his tendency towards the long-ball. It would appear that the spacious Citibank Park in El Paso is a good fit for Chuck-Mo.
Grade: A
Mexico City Jalapenos
In the off-season the Jalapenos signed a list of free-agents including Gregory Franklin, Walter Milton and Miguel Johnson. As a result, their only pick in the top 100 was a supplemental pick at #60 which they used to select second baseman Lee Stocker. A borderline option at best, Stocker doesn’t quite show the promise that one would expect from a top draft prospect. It wouldn’t seem fair to judge M.C. on Stocker, however, but instead on the long-term returns that the franchise sees on their off-season spending.
Grade: N/A
Montgomery Burns
With poor drafting position, Montgomery burnt their opportunity to secure any potential major league talent. Sturdy shortstop Kenneth Gray has an error-prone glove and a bench bat at best. Workhorse chucker Stan Larkin is under-powering, erratic and shaky under pressure. Frail outfielder Trevor has a sloppy glove and has outside potential for a vs. lefties platoon role. In all, the Burns are more focused on the standings than the amateur draft.
Grade: D
N.L. West
Helena Phantom der Nacht
One of the safer ways to make use of a late draft pick is to find a useful reliever. Many GMs feel that there is less value in an arm that will top out at an inning or two of work per appearance, but by the end of the first round an effective reliever like the undersized Dingo Burba is a good idea. Burba is a durable fire-baller/knuckle-baller who is good to throw out there almost every day. To be a premiere ML reliever, he’ll need to work on developing his slider and keeping the ball down in the strike zone to avoid the long ball.
Supplemental pick Melvin Carpenter is a good shortstop who could carve out a niche as a defensive specialist. Otherwise his potential is fairly limited.
Grade: B
L.A. Dead Bunnies
The Bunnies signed former Rodeo Clown pitcher Gerald Oliva and thus forfeited their first round pick. Starting at pick #85, L.A. really didn’t have much to work with this time around. They likely didn’t take a player who will reach the pro level, but with their late draft position it’s difficult to judge the quality of their draft execution.
Grade: N/A
San Fransisco Streets
With their top selection, San Fran opted for the athletic Quinton Hargrave to man the hot corner. The quotable and outgoing Hargrave will be an instant fan favorite for his enthusiasm and competitiveness. He has the potential to be a decent fielder, but the real strength is in his bat which should make an impact at the major league level. Displaying good power and the ability to drive the ball to all fields, Hargrave is prone to swing for the fences and suffers the resulting high strikeout total. Showing good speed and reckless hustle on the bases, his overzealous running will on occasion result in poor decisions. A worthy first rounder, Hargrave will be joined on the Streets by stocky catcher Brian Castellanos and the versatile Jack Long. Castellanos has an exceptional throwing arm, but may or may not be able to fully handle ML catching responsibilities. He won’t hit for average, but he has serious major league power that will press San Fran to find him at bats. Jack Long is indeed a “Jack” of all trades in the field, with a throwing arm that would be at home in right field or third base. He won’t often hit for power, but he has the chance to provide value at the dish as well as in the field.
Grade: A
Vancouver Vampire Bats
With five picks in the top fifty, the V-Bats had a chance to impact the franchise with this season’s draft. With their top pick, they opted for left-handed pitcher Jhonny Torres, a poised twenty two yr old with excellent control and lots of good breaking stuff. He’s really tough on lefties and should provide Vancouver with a front end starter if he can turn his fastball into a major league pitch (which is still a question mark). The rock-solid Rico Ciriaco would be better option if he could stay more focused in the field. He’s likely a major league caliber hitter if they can get him to settle into a fielding role. Saskatchewan-born relief pitcher Scott Harper has the potential to be really good in a short role, bringing a sick curveball and tough mound mentality. Catcher Felipe James manages pitchers like a chess master and has some good bat skill as well. The question mark might be about his ability to catch every day, as he has a reputation for burning out easily. The V-Bats have restocked the cupboard with four players with moderate to good potential.
Grade: A
A.L. North
Ottawa Hosers
Center fielder Wilton Benes is a defense-first athlete who projects to be a part time player at best. The Hosers like his intangibles, such as bunting and baserunning and see him down the road as a fifth outfielder who can pinch hit vs lefties. Catcher Giovanni Pelfrey is a capable defensive catcher, but with limited bat-skill he’ll never likely reach the professional level. Pelfrey looks to be an asset handling young pitchers through the Hosers minor league system. A forgettable draft for Ottawa this time around.
Grade: D-
Syracuse Blue Sox
With the 9th pick in this season’s draft, the Blue Sox were happy to see talented Kimera Rhodes fall to them. Rhodes could have been a top 3 pick if he didn’t come with some health concerns, making him a high risk-high reward selection for Syracuse. A solid all-around player, Rhodes can hit for both power and average, while boasting decent speed and a strong arm. Outfielder Luis Noesi shows some promise as a solid hitter with great speed. A criticism of the lefty-hitting Noesi is in the field, where his weak glove-work could make him a liability in left or right. Defensively more of a first-baseman, Noesi probably doesn’t have the offensive impact that most teams look for from first. Pitcher Steve Becker shows some promise with a great fastball and pin-point control. He projects to be a solid late-inning arm for the Sox.
Grade: A
Toronto Trout
With pick #20, the Trout selected shortstop Raymond Miller, an excellent defender who likely won’t boast the offensive chops needed to make waves as a pro. Miller has blazing speed and good instincts, which should get him as far as one can get without being a threat at the plate. He has a history of hamstring problems, so Toronto will need to keep the training/medical staff on their toes.
Grade: C-
Trenton Terror Hawks
Pitcher Nick Austin could prove to be a steal for the Terror Hawks. While he won’t blow away any radar guns, Austin has excellent stuff and looks like a top of the rotation starter if the 18 yr old develops well through the Trenton minor league system. They’ll need to monitor his inning-count going forward, but he represents excellent potential. Outfielder Rey Sheldon has some great raw skills, but his work ethic might need to evolve if he’s to be a contributor. If Sheldon stays in shape and avoids trouble away from the ballpark, he could mature into a solid center fielder, a good contact hitter and an offensive sparkplug.
Grade: A-
A.L. East
Boston Red Sox
The Red Sox admittedly didn’t exercise due diligence in this season’s draft prep, and the selection of “Wild” Juan Olmedo demonstrates this. Olmedo is a strange animal: the shocking velocity on his knuckleball is something hard to grasp, however, he has tons of trouble finding the strike zone and doesn’t look likely to improve in this regard. Boston could certainly have used this pick more wisely. The selection of left fielder Lou McQuillan is a safe one, as the steady outfielder has a potential major league bat. He has trouble in the field and he’ll never be a star, but with some hard work McQuillan could turn into a lunchbox-style pro player. Catcher Bill Sosa can handle himself adequately behind the dish and also brings some hitting ability, however, neither Sosa or McQuillan will likely be at the heart of the Sox rebuilding efforts.
Grade: D+
Durham County Ramblers
With pick #15, Durham had to be pleased to land righty Raymond James. The 20 year old James looks like a workhorse, and though he might serve up a few fly balls in the home run park, his core attributes are sensational. A knock on James might be that he only has a three pitch arsenal, including a fairly mediocre forkball. To be really successful, his fastball and curve will need to be coached into serious “big league” caliber pitches. The Ramblers followed the James selection with three hitters who won’t be oft lauded for defense. Timo Conroy is a durable contact hitter whose strength is hitting lefties. Cecil Brennaman and Joakim Johnson are patient sluggers who could be successful as major league power threats if they can also hit for a reasonable batting average.
Grade: B+
Jacksonville Sunbirds
The Sunbirds chose highly touted outfielder Dan Burke with the 8th pick in the draft and he’s the real deal. Burke, who some scouts felt could have gone a few spots higher, is a prototypical leadoff man. Boasting fantastic speed and great instincts, the athletic Burke hits lefties well and even has some surprising power. The only knock on Burke is his defense, which although adequate for a left-fielder, raises questions about how someone with such great speed can have such an ordinary range in the field. Jacksonville followed up with two pitchers, Jimmy Giambi and Nick Lowery. Lowery has some promise, but will really need all the help he can get to progress to a high level. Giambi is only 5’8” - almost unheard of for a pitcher, but he could prove useful out of the bullpen if his forkball gets a little better.
Grade: B
New York Crunch
Due to their off-season free agent acquisitions, the Crunch only had two selections in the top five rounds. With the 14th pick, they did well to draft Domingo Acosta, who has drawn comparisons to Dan Burke in terms of his speed, leadoff abilities and lack of fielding acumen. Acosta has the makings of a very intelligent hitter, with great plate patience and the ability to drive the ball to all fields. Acosta has elected to bypass his senior year at Southern Illinois to start his baseball career as a 21 year old. The Crunch also chose smallish second baseman Hal Ryan, also very fleet of foot with fair hitting ability. Ryan will need to find a way to cut down on the mistakes in all areas of his game, as he’s prone to base-running blunders, as well as poor glove work by middle-infielder standards. He’ll need to work his tail off for an opportunity, as he doesn’t have nearly as much talent as Acosta.
Grade: B
A.L. South
Charlotte Designated Drinkers
The Drinkers consider themselves quite fortunate to land towering righty Pedro Martin with the 22nd pick. Martin is a strong kid, who could turn into a top-tier starter capable of throwing well over 200 innings per year. Without a serious “go to” pitch and a tendency towards fly balls, Martin will need to rely on his excellent control and four developing pitches to outsmart hitters instead of overpowering them. Only 18 years old, scouts will no doubt be monitoring his rise through the Charlotte system. First baseman Al Dunston is a safe pick, but doesn’t have the star offensive potential that many like to see from first base. Third round southpaw Dwight Weaver throws a crafty fastball-forkball mix that gives left-handed hitters trouble. He could be a long term option for the D.D’s bullpen.
Grade: A-
Florida GATORs
The Gators opted for long-term projects with their high draft picks, taking 18 year olds with their first three choices. First rounder Mark Lawton is exceptionally quick, both on the bases and covering territory at shortstop. Lawton has a much easier time hitting lefties, and will need to make seriously significant strides to become a relevant offensive player. In the field, he has a strong arm and will only need to cut down on mistakes to be effective. Alex Sweeney and Gabe McEnroe are both close to being at a pro level defensively, while likely never offering more than fleeting success at the plate. Not a winning draft for Florida in terms of building blocks for the franchise.
Grade: D
Louisville Lobsters
With the 21st pick the Lobsters chose pitcher Mark Quinn, an undersized left-handed pitcher with good control and a decent arsenal of pitches. Quinn has yet to sign in Louisville and has expressed a preference for football over baseball. It looks like the Lobsters will need to settle for a compensation pick next season. Beyond the first round, Louisville has nothing to be thrilled about with 5’9” pitcher Bryce Flores struggling with his control and outfielders Enrique Blanco and Rick Rehfield looking like long-shots for anything more than fleeting success. The Lobsters didn’t take a player over six feet tall until the fifth round!
Grade: C-
Nashville Catfish
Despite what appears to be a very meticulous draft plan, the Catfish may regret their first round selection of pitcher Brad Burks. Renowned for his patience, Burks has five average pitches but doesn’t really excel in any areas. Just out of high school, he’ll need to show serious signs of improvement if he’s going to be more than just another pretty arm. Nashville also selected a duo of catchers, including the highly-touted Puerto Rican Junior Pelaez and the more limited Dwight Johnstone. Pelaez was the top catcher in the draft according to some scouts, as he boasts a rifle arm and sound fundamentals behind the plate to go along with a dangerous bat. With great plate patience and home run potential, Pelaez might struggle with his batting average as he has a tough time adjusting to inside pitches from righties. If he stays healthy, Pelaez has a very high ceiling. If he doesn’t stay healthy, then at least they have Dwight Johnstone. Johnstone is decent behind the plate and can hit well enough to stay in the lineup. Not being able to withstand the rigors of a full season, he’s ideally suited for backup work (which is his preference). The Catfish took 3rd baseman Daniel Wise in the 4th round and he’s a bonafide slugger and strikeout aficionado who will never hit for average but projects to a 30 HR guy at minimum. The qualities of second rounder, pitcher Calvin Punto are unknown. The ‘fish are keeping Punto’s identity close to the vest.
Grade: B
A.L. West
Las Vegas Numa Numa
Consistently adept at finding skilled talent despite mediocre drafting position, Vegas once again obtained a nice asset with their top choice Charlie Torres. A great contact hitter with moderate power and deceptive speed, Torres is a good clubhouse guy who should bring a stable if unspectacular presence to the Numa Numa. Torres’ weaknesses focus around his hand-eye coordination, as is demonstrated by his poor throwing arm and his embarrassing inability to lay down a bunt. Infielders Lazy Albers and Alex Ordaz are lunchbox guys who could wind up filling some useful bench roles, and in the case of Albers a potentially versatile fielding specialist. Hard-throwing pitcher Rick Franklin shows some flashes of promise, but will have a hard time getting very far unless his fastball vastly improves.
Grade: B
Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns
The Clowns’ scouts almost entirely steer clear of colleges in favor of spending their time hanging around high schools instead. The club only took one player over 18 amongst their first fifteen picks and 20/25 picks were 18 year olds. With three picks in the top 40, the Clowns selected two pitchers and a left fielder – all youngsters with some time to improve. Clarence Shuck is a pure “location pitcher” with five options in his arsenal. His rise through the system will determine whether he has the stamina to join the rotation and whether the “fly-ball” hurler has the craftiness to make outs at the top level. Raul Gabriel is a short reliever by pedigree and should be able to pitch almost every day. He was among Central Scouting’s top-rated relievers in this season’s draft and looks like a great value at pick 28. Gabriel doesn’t have high 90’s stuff, but his fastball has tons of movement and is a serious “out pitch”. Left fielder Santos Mercedes is the cousin of all-world slugger Alfonso, but he doesn’t have the family power or likely enough to win a starting job. He’s a low-ceiling flier pick who will need some serious coaching to turn the corner.
Grade: B-
Salem Sanguillens
With the #10 pick in the draft, Salem chose outfielder Walt O’Neill. A hitter with major league upside and good athletic ability, O’Neill isn’t flashy and won’t likely be a star. Not blessed with great speed, and only displaying moderate power, the teenager from Ohio is a guy who knows how to get on base and comes ready to play every day. O’Neill’s defense doesn’t have a wow factor, so he’ll need to be a steady clutch hitter and take advantage of his opportunities. He’s projected to reach 90/18/75/.285 levels if he’s in a solid lineup. Other Sanguillen choices of note are 5’9” pitcher Stu Nixon who will need to overcome problems with control and fly balls, and 5’5” infielder Joey Evans who looks like a utility defensive backup with limited offensive potential.
Grade: C+
Scottsdale Fighting Chokes
The Chokes took one of the top starting pitchers in this season’s draft class. Towering 6’7” Japanese-American Ozzie Tamura has serious potential if he can stay healthy. A workhorse-style starter, Tamura has already had two shoulder surgeries by age 18 and his awkward delivery makes him a risk for further complications. If he’s careful with his valuable arm, Tamura shows three ML caliber pitches and impressive poise and control. He’ll need to work on keeping the ball down in the strike zone, but he should be a front end starter for Scottsdale. 33rd pick Julio Tarasco also has some promise, and though he isn’t overpowering he doesn’t have any glaring weakness either. He might wind up in the bullpen if he doesn’t build his stamina.
Grade: B+
N.L. North
Chicago Crushers
With the second overall pick this time around, Chicago continued with their focus on acquiring front end starting pitching and selected 21 year old southpaw Jerome Johnson. With perhaps the best slider some scouts have encountered, Johnson is close to “can’t miss” with brilliant command and a well-developed arsenal to keep hitters off-balance. “JJ” is especially tough vs left-handed batters and how he develops against righties will determine whether he’ll be good or great. The Crushers also selected shortstop Vic Wainwright, he of slick glove and strong arm who may benefit with a move to third base down the road. Wainwright shows good bat contact, moderate power and should be able to contribute offense at a ML level. Hard throwing Regan Flaherty has a brilliant fastball and looks to have potential for improvement, though his durability issues may force him to the bullpen. There are some concerns about Flaherty’s control, but if he can overcome those issues he could be a useful piece.
Grade: A
Detroit Tiger Sharks
Lefty Louie Pujols is hard to evaluate. On one hand, his location is deadly accurate and he can surprise the radar gun and hitters with the combination of velocity and movement on his pitches. On the other, Pujols can be stubborn with his pitch selection and might rely too heavily on a slider that hitters can make adjustments for. He also has a tendency to leave hittable pitches out over the plate for right-handed hitters to feast on. Only 18, Pujols is still quite raw and if he can develop better consistency and avoid shoulder trouble he could turn into a prized asset for the Tiger Sharks. Detroit’s subsequent selections (pitcher Barry Lanier; second bagger Bryce Dodson; center fielder Jair Bennett) all have some winning attributes, but at the end of the day aren’t complete major league players.
Grade: B
Montreal Maroons
The Maroons haven’t been allocating money for amateur scouting in quite some time. This is reflected in their lack of any promising talent in this season’s amateur draft. Supplemental picks Sherman Wise (p), Robinzon Lee (2b) and Steve Hill (ss) most likely represent a AAA ceiling. Montreal continues to focus on recruiting international talent, meaning that newly inked phenomenal Mexican phenom Felipe Lee is more than an adequate reason to be satisfied with a poor drafting grade.
Grade: F
Philadelphia Pheremoniacs
The lower the pick in the first round, the greater the risk of missing the mark. With pick #23, Philly went as low risk as possible, taking stocky relief man Stephen Saunders. Scouts say the 19 year old community college student from Michigan is a great teammate and strong leader with fairly dependable arsenal well suited for late-inning success as a major leaguer. Saunders is the only selection of note this season for Philly, but it’s certainly not a wasted choice.
Grade: B
N.L. East
Baltimore Barons
Felix Ross has been compared on several occasions to former major leaguer Ozzie Smith. The Baron’s #3 overall selection is a wizard in his own right, extremely agile and light on his feet with a surprising arm – powerful and accurate from shallow left field, Ross is excellent throwing across his body while moving to his right. Not known for his offense, Ross brings intelligence to the plate. Patient, with good hand-eye coordination he’s a decent contact hitter but doesn’t have the strength to consistently drive the ball with much power. The Barons will be thrilled if their future gold glove candidate is good for a .270 average with 10-12 home runs per season.
Grade: B+
Cincinnati Red Army
With their first choice at #11, the Red Army was happy to see shortstop Chico Villafuerte still on the board. In the conversation with Gene Gold and Felix Ross as the top shortstops in this season’s draft, Villafuerte is still a raw commodity. Blessed with eye-popping speed on the bases and a howitzer for an arm, Cincy’s top choice will need to learn better plate patience and improve his glove work. A lock to be a major leaguer down the road, some scouts see Villafuerte as a third baseman whose overall value depends on how he develops as a hitter. With pick #51, the Army chose pitcher Archie Camilli, a steal at his draft position and a potential mid rotation ML starter. A hard worker with excellent control, the 18 year old has developed a knuckleball as the key feature of his varied arsenal. He’s a smart pitcher with a decent future. Cincinatti should be reasonably happy with their draft value this season.
Grade:A
New York New Jerseys
The N.Y.N.J.’s have landed themselves a couple of solid defensive assets in center fielder Bronson Cishek and corner man Joaquin Gonzales. Many scouts consider Cishek to be the best center fielder available in this year’s crop. He’s a natural at getting a great read on initial contact and the result is that Cishek covers a large portion of the outfield, often taking pressure off his corner-outfield teammates. Not know as an offensive threat, the left-handed Cishek can contribute decently against right handed pitching and his ultimate value in the batter’s box will be determined by how coachable the 18 year old is as he matures. Gonzales is a solid, but unspectacular player with a strong throwing arm who can play several positions well. He makes decent contact at the plate, but doesn’t project to make an offensive impact at the pro level. Neither player should be an integral part of the success or failure of the franchise. All things considered, not the most impactful draft for New York.
Grade: C
Washington Swamp Cats
Coming off a stellar 106-win season, the Swamp Cats were dealing with poor draft position and didn’t have high hopes. Selecting 6’5” high school pitcher Junior Garvin is a solid move for the Cats. Boasting five pitches, a strong arm and generally decent stuff, Garvin’s Achilles heel is his erratic control, which could hinder his reliability but shouldn’t prevent him from being an effective major league pitcher. Not a bad value at the 31st pick of the draft.
Grade: B
N.L. South
Charleston Cannons
With the top overall selection in this season’s draft, the Cannons didn’t hesitate to select shortstop Gene Gold. While many scouts consider Gold to be the best “all around” player in the draft, he doesn’t blow away the field in any area. A good athlete, Gold has some speed, is a solid hitter and represents himself well in the field. However, for a #1 overall shortstop pick, Gold doesn’t approach Ross in the field, nor does he have the raw speed and cannon arm of Villafuerte, but the Cannons hope that when they look back on the draft they’ve chosen the shortstop who can make the greatest offensive impact. The Cannons also chose location-challenged curveball specialist Alberto Quevedo, who might struggle to blow away major league hitting.
Grade: A-
El Paso Blancos
The Blancos’ only significant selection this time around was #6 pick, southpaw hurler Charlie Moore. A very motivated potential top of the rotation starter, Moore has a good fastball, a high compete level and no glaring weaknesses. For a pitcher of his potential to reach his ceiling, El Paso will need to handle his workload carefully and hope that he can eventually be able to routinely throw 200+ innings per season. To nit-pick a potential weakness from Moore would be his tendency towards the long-ball. It would appear that the spacious Citibank Park in El Paso is a good fit for Chuck-Mo.
Grade: A
Mexico City Jalapenos
In the off-season the Jalapenos signed a list of free-agents including Gregory Franklin, Walter Milton and Miguel Johnson. As a result, their only pick in the top 100 was a supplemental pick at #60 which they used to select second baseman Lee Stocker. A borderline option at best, Stocker doesn’t quite show the promise that one would expect from a top draft prospect. It wouldn’t seem fair to judge M.C. on Stocker, however, but instead on the long-term returns that the franchise sees on their off-season spending.
Grade: N/A
Montgomery Burns
With poor drafting position, Montgomery burnt their opportunity to secure any potential major league talent. Sturdy shortstop Kenneth Gray has an error-prone glove and a bench bat at best. Workhorse chucker Stan Larkin is under-powering, erratic and shaky under pressure. Frail outfielder Trevor has a sloppy glove and has outside potential for a vs. lefties platoon role. In all, the Burns are more focused on the standings than the amateur draft.
Grade: D
N.L. West
Helena Phantom der Nacht
One of the safer ways to make use of a late draft pick is to find a useful reliever. Many GMs feel that there is less value in an arm that will top out at an inning or two of work per appearance, but by the end of the first round an effective reliever like the undersized Dingo Burba is a good idea. Burba is a durable fire-baller/knuckle-baller who is good to throw out there almost every day. To be a premiere ML reliever, he’ll need to work on developing his slider and keeping the ball down in the strike zone to avoid the long ball.
Supplemental pick Melvin Carpenter is a good shortstop who could carve out a niche as a defensive specialist. Otherwise his potential is fairly limited.
Grade: B
L.A. Dead Bunnies
The Bunnies signed former Rodeo Clown pitcher Gerald Oliva and thus forfeited their first round pick. Starting at pick #85, L.A. really didn’t have much to work with this time around. They likely didn’t take a player who will reach the pro level, but with their late draft position it’s difficult to judge the quality of their draft execution.
Grade: N/A
San Fransisco Streets
With their top selection, San Fran opted for the athletic Quinton Hargrave to man the hot corner. The quotable and outgoing Hargrave will be an instant fan favorite for his enthusiasm and competitiveness. He has the potential to be a decent fielder, but the real strength is in his bat which should make an impact at the major league level. Displaying good power and the ability to drive the ball to all fields, Hargrave is prone to swing for the fences and suffers the resulting high strikeout total. Showing good speed and reckless hustle on the bases, his overzealous running will on occasion result in poor decisions. A worthy first rounder, Hargrave will be joined on the Streets by stocky catcher Brian Castellanos and the versatile Jack Long. Castellanos has an exceptional throwing arm, but may or may not be able to fully handle ML catching responsibilities. He won’t hit for average, but he has serious major league power that will press San Fran to find him at bats. Jack Long is indeed a “Jack” of all trades in the field, with a throwing arm that would be at home in right field or third base. He won’t often hit for power, but he has the chance to provide value at the dish as well as in the field.
Grade: A
Vancouver Vampire Bats
With five picks in the top fifty, the V-Bats had a chance to impact the franchise with this season’s draft. With their top pick, they opted for left-handed pitcher Jhonny Torres, a poised twenty two yr old with excellent control and lots of good breaking stuff. He’s really tough on lefties and should provide Vancouver with a front end starter if he can turn his fastball into a major league pitch (which is still a question mark). The rock-solid Rico Ciriaco would be better option if he could stay more focused in the field. He’s likely a major league caliber hitter if they can get him to settle into a fielding role. Saskatchewan-born relief pitcher Scott Harper has the potential to be really good in a short role, bringing a sick curveball and tough mound mentality. Catcher Felipe James manages pitchers like a chess master and has some good bat skill as well. The question mark might be about his ability to catch every day, as he has a reputation for burning out easily. The V-Bats have restocked the cupboard with four players with moderate to good potential.
Grade: A
International Free Agent Report
Season 22 has not exactly been a banner year for international talent. Let's have a look at a few of the better prospects that have been signed this season. I will list them by the amount of prospect bonus money spent on them, so don't look at this as an attempt to rank them.
First on the list is Olmedo Guillen, a Venezualan starting pitcher signed by the Cincinnati Red Army. By plunking down a cool 23.1 million dollar signing bonus, Cincinnati has indicated that they look to become a major player in the international market. This looks to be money well spent, because the 18 year old Guillen projects to be a solid number two type of starting pitcher. He projects to have excellent control, has good velocity, above average splits, and his pitch arsenal will feature a very good 4-seam fastball, a good curve, and average cut fastball and changeup. He should be durable enough to pitch 230 innings of sub-4 ERA ball per season. Although he's not the next Villa or Vasco, he might just turn out to be the top international signing this season.
Next up we will look at Mexican Felipe Lee, who Montreal added to their stable of fine young International pitchers for $18.7 M, with a spring training invite. Although this 18 year old probably won't have the ability to handle the type of workload that Guillen will, Lee just might be the most skilled pitcher signed as an international free agent this season. He projects to have some pretty dominating stuff, including high end splits, first class velocity, and five pitches, of which his sinker and curveball project to be elite. It also looks like he'll strongly tend to be a groundball pitcher, and should have good enough command of the strike zone be effective. As touched upon earlier, the only knock on this kid is that he might not be able to handle the type of workload of a starting pitcher, so look for Montreal to groom him to be a setup guy or two-inning closer. His ability to stay healthy might be an issue in the end as well.
The most highly touted positional IFA this season so far was signed by Baltimore. Although he is listed as a SS right now, Albie Nieto might be better suited to play 3B in the end. Baltimore signed this 18 year old Mexican prodigy to a MLB contract, with $18 million in bonus money. That type of money and contract should probably be money well spent, since this guy looks to be a veritable 5 tool player. This switch hitter projects to feature good power and batting average, excellent speed and decent baserunning abilities, and either plus defensive ability and arm strength for the 3b position, or sub par defensive skills for shortstop. His only real drawback, minor as it is, is that he might not end up with enough durability to start 162 games per season. All in all, Baltimore made a good buy for this kid, who projects to be a solid Major League player. He might even earn himself some all-star nods before his career is through.
Another 18 year old, Dominican Yovani Lucano is next on our list. It took an $18 M bonus to get this kid signed to a minor league deal, and Durham was happy to do so. He projects to have the tools to be an effective number three type of starting pitcher. He won't be able to eat the type of innings that Olmedo Guillen will, but he should be effective when he's on the mound. Although he won't have dominating stuff, he also doesn't seem to have any weaknesses to his skillset either. Some might argue that spending 18 million to get an average starting pitcher is a bit of a high price, but when you average out that cost over the 5 seasons of minimal price that Durham will pay to get the services of a solid MLer, it looks like money well spent to me. At the end of his cheap years, Durham could also pick up a probable type B pick should Lucano sign elsewhere as a free agent.
The last big money signing this season was for 18 year old Venezuelan C/DH Jimmie Mangual. Las Vegas had to pony up $17.5 M and a MLB deal to get this kid's name on the dotted line, which is probably an overpayment, but at the end of the season, it's definitely better to overpay rather than get nothing. As for the kid's skills, it looks like he could become quite an effective ML hitter, with good projections for his contact skills, batting eye and versus right, and to a lesser extent versus left splits. His projects to have decent power - good extra base power, but he'll never be at the top of the list for home runs. As for his defensive abilities, it looks like he might come up short in the pitch calling department, and his range, although he's a catcher, might not make the grade either, meaning he won't be so good at blocking the plate. On the plus side, his arm strength and accuracy should make him a tough catcher to steal bases against. All in all, it's probably a good thing that Las Vegas plays in the AL, because this guy might be best suited to suit up as a DH, with spot duties filling in as a C when needed. All things being equal, there is no way that this guy deserves the signing bonus that he got, but as noted earlier, when the season is winding down, and you know that there won't be any more IFAs showing up, it's better to overpay for the best of what's left rather than being stuck holding a big bag of money and having nothing to spend it on.
Toronto waded into the international free agent pool to nab 21 year old Latino Frenchman Brady Vasquez for a $10.6 M bonus to go with a minor league deal. Although at the age of 21 he might not be developing much more, he is capable of pitching in the ML right now as a setup B kind of reliever. That's the kind of price that you have to pay to get ML talent in the international market these days. Most of Vasquez's skill set might leave something to be desired, but he has no holes in his game, and actually features a couple of dominating pitches, being his knuckleball and 4-seam fastball. He won't be winning any awards in his career, but Toronto can expect to get 50-60 solid, unspectacular innings per season out of this guy for cheap.
Those who cringe at the amount of money that gets splashed around in the international market might point to Vasquez, and Philidelphia's signing of Diory Alburquerque as cringe-worthy. But, the question needs to be asked - What else are they going to spend their prospect budget on? Alas, this is an argument for another day. As for Alburquerque, (I love typing out that name!), he projects to be another setup B type of talent, who should "max" out at 40-50 IP per season. This 18 year old's first pitch, a 4-seam fastball, could top out at an elite level, but his other two pitches (cut FB, curve) as well as the rest of his skill set, project to be decidedly pedestrian ML stuff.
It looks like Boston might have gotten better value for their $9.6 M than Toronto and Philly for their $10.6 M and $10.1 M. With the signing of 18 year old Panamanian Al Javier to a Major League deal, Boston has picked up a setup guy who's skill-set and durability looks to top out at a higher level thank Vazquez or Alburquerque. He projects to be able to pitch up to 100 IP, and has the skills to make them count. His two pitches, a 4-seamer and change up project to be dominating and good. His splits might be only average, and he might not get good velocity, but he should have good control and (very important for a pitcher in Boston!) looks to be a decent groundballer. Overall, this looks to be money well spent for Boston.
By signing Ramon Nomo to a $9.1 M deal with a spring training invite, it looks like Montgomery has picked up a pretty good value. This 20 year old Japanese starting pitcher projects to have some good enough stuff to be a decent back of the rotation type of starter or long reliever. At this point in his development, he could handle ML duties as a LRB or mopup guy, but with a bit of seasoning in the minors, he could turn out to be something a bit more valuable. It looks like he should be able to eat innings if called upon, and although he'll never be able to blow pitches by ML batters, the rest of his skill set should be able to make him at least effective at keeping his team in the game.
El Paso are please to not have wasted a good chunk of their prospect cash by signing Juan Moraga. This 18 year old Cuban defector signed a minor league contract with a spring training invite and a $9 M bonus. Considering how terrible El Paso's international scouts are, they should count themselves lucky to have seen any prospects worth signing at all. Moraga is definitely an intriguing prospect. He has ML power already, and that should improve to world class power. He projects to having a very good eye for the strike zone, and despite being a RHB, he seems to have a better ability at the plate against right-handed pitching than left. he does have a couple of weaknesses, mainly that he will strike out a lot, and also his glove might not end up to be satisfactory for ML right field duties. However, right field isn't a bad place to hide a bad glove, and his range and arm should be more than adequate for the position. All in all, this was a good move by El Paso's management, to be able to get something of value from the international market so late in the season, and with such a skeleton crew of international scouts that they have.
Next on our list might be one of the best value signings from the IFA market so far this season. By only paying $6.9 M with a minor league deal to secure the services of the 18 year old Cuban defector first baseman Vin Perez, Vancouver might just have landed themselves a potentially decent ML starter for a bargain basement price. This left-handed batter projects to have 30 hr potential, and his OBP could hover around .400. There is a real potential for this guy to average around .850 in OPS. What else can I say? Although he's a LHB, it looks like he should be able to handle left-handed pitching well enough to not need to platoon him, and his contact ability should keep him from striking out too much. His only knock is that he might not end up with the durability to start every game over a 162 game schedule, and that he probably won't ever be a 50 hr hitter. He should rack up the doubles though, so it still looks like Vancouver might have locked up a hitter to fill in the # 3 or 4 slot in their batting order for what relatively amounts to peanuts!
For $5.8 M, San Francisco inked 19 year old Irish OF Stan Morton to a minor league deal. Although he is a switch hitter, that ability is wasted, because he will only have the ability to hit left-handed pitching effectively. He has speed to burn, and also has good power at the plate, so the money spent on this guy is not too bad, considering that he might just top out as a bench/platoon player. I might be proved wrong though - San Fran could end up starting him in the Bigs, since he does have a good eye for the strike zone, and it looks like he might end up killing versus lefties. His batting average probably won't be good, but his OPS might get to .800 some seasons, so he's not all bad. Plus he'll play a gold glove corner outfield.
Rivaling Vin Perez for value might be the signing of Maicer Castro. This 18 year old Venezuelan starting pitcher signed a minor league deal with Salem for a paltry $5.7 M. He looks to have all of the skills to be a solid # 3 starter. He projects to have decent abilities across the board, with the exception of the fact that he looks to be a flyball pitcher in the end. Perhaps his ability against lefthanded batting might limit his effectiveness, and he could run into injury trouble in his career, but with so little spent to get his name on a contract, Salem has little to lose.
By getting Dominican 2b Carlos Palmeiro to sign a minor league deal with a spring training invite for a mere $5.1 M, Florida have also gotten themselves a nice bargain. It looks like Palmeiro should be able to handle ML 2b duties, and his offensive abilities should be good enough to justify him taking up a spot on a ML roster. His hitting abilities versus right-handed pitching might not get to the point where he will hit for a good average, but his speed and decent eye should help him get on base by legging out infield hits and earning walks. He'll probably never come close to 20 home runs, but who expects power hitting from the middle infield anyway? He has some good tools in his box, such as a decent ability to get the bat on the ball, the aforementioned speed and base-running ability, and he'll be able to bunt with the best of them. Combine that with a good ability to hit left handed pitching and solid defense, and Florida has themselves a decent prospect for the money.
Also filed under the "bargain" heading is San Francisco's signing of Dominican 18 year old RHP J.P. Peguero. By getting him into the fold at $4.2 M for a minor league deal, San Francisco might have picked up an effective bullpen arm for an extremely low price. His ability to pitch against left-handed batting might not ever be dominant, but he projects to shut righties down pretty effectively. It also looks like he could end up with good command of the strike zone, and has three solid pitches. On the down side, injuries could hamper his development, and he has the undesirable combination of low velocity and is a flyball pitcher. That spells homeruns allowed to me. However, for the low price that was paid for him, this guy will provide solid, but unspectacular numbers for his team, as long as he stays healthy.
First on the list is Olmedo Guillen, a Venezualan starting pitcher signed by the Cincinnati Red Army. By plunking down a cool 23.1 million dollar signing bonus, Cincinnati has indicated that they look to become a major player in the international market. This looks to be money well spent, because the 18 year old Guillen projects to be a solid number two type of starting pitcher. He projects to have excellent control, has good velocity, above average splits, and his pitch arsenal will feature a very good 4-seam fastball, a good curve, and average cut fastball and changeup. He should be durable enough to pitch 230 innings of sub-4 ERA ball per season. Although he's not the next Villa or Vasco, he might just turn out to be the top international signing this season.
Next up we will look at Mexican Felipe Lee, who Montreal added to their stable of fine young International pitchers for $18.7 M, with a spring training invite. Although this 18 year old probably won't have the ability to handle the type of workload that Guillen will, Lee just might be the most skilled pitcher signed as an international free agent this season. He projects to have some pretty dominating stuff, including high end splits, first class velocity, and five pitches, of which his sinker and curveball project to be elite. It also looks like he'll strongly tend to be a groundball pitcher, and should have good enough command of the strike zone be effective. As touched upon earlier, the only knock on this kid is that he might not be able to handle the type of workload of a starting pitcher, so look for Montreal to groom him to be a setup guy or two-inning closer. His ability to stay healthy might be an issue in the end as well.
The most highly touted positional IFA this season so far was signed by Baltimore. Although he is listed as a SS right now, Albie Nieto might be better suited to play 3B in the end. Baltimore signed this 18 year old Mexican prodigy to a MLB contract, with $18 million in bonus money. That type of money and contract should probably be money well spent, since this guy looks to be a veritable 5 tool player. This switch hitter projects to feature good power and batting average, excellent speed and decent baserunning abilities, and either plus defensive ability and arm strength for the 3b position, or sub par defensive skills for shortstop. His only real drawback, minor as it is, is that he might not end up with enough durability to start 162 games per season. All in all, Baltimore made a good buy for this kid, who projects to be a solid Major League player. He might even earn himself some all-star nods before his career is through.
Another 18 year old, Dominican Yovani Lucano is next on our list. It took an $18 M bonus to get this kid signed to a minor league deal, and Durham was happy to do so. He projects to have the tools to be an effective number three type of starting pitcher. He won't be able to eat the type of innings that Olmedo Guillen will, but he should be effective when he's on the mound. Although he won't have dominating stuff, he also doesn't seem to have any weaknesses to his skillset either. Some might argue that spending 18 million to get an average starting pitcher is a bit of a high price, but when you average out that cost over the 5 seasons of minimal price that Durham will pay to get the services of a solid MLer, it looks like money well spent to me. At the end of his cheap years, Durham could also pick up a probable type B pick should Lucano sign elsewhere as a free agent.
The last big money signing this season was for 18 year old Venezuelan C/DH Jimmie Mangual. Las Vegas had to pony up $17.5 M and a MLB deal to get this kid's name on the dotted line, which is probably an overpayment, but at the end of the season, it's definitely better to overpay rather than get nothing. As for the kid's skills, it looks like he could become quite an effective ML hitter, with good projections for his contact skills, batting eye and versus right, and to a lesser extent versus left splits. His projects to have decent power - good extra base power, but he'll never be at the top of the list for home runs. As for his defensive abilities, it looks like he might come up short in the pitch calling department, and his range, although he's a catcher, might not make the grade either, meaning he won't be so good at blocking the plate. On the plus side, his arm strength and accuracy should make him a tough catcher to steal bases against. All in all, it's probably a good thing that Las Vegas plays in the AL, because this guy might be best suited to suit up as a DH, with spot duties filling in as a C when needed. All things being equal, there is no way that this guy deserves the signing bonus that he got, but as noted earlier, when the season is winding down, and you know that there won't be any more IFAs showing up, it's better to overpay for the best of what's left rather than being stuck holding a big bag of money and having nothing to spend it on.
Toronto waded into the international free agent pool to nab 21 year old Latino Frenchman Brady Vasquez for a $10.6 M bonus to go with a minor league deal. Although at the age of 21 he might not be developing much more, he is capable of pitching in the ML right now as a setup B kind of reliever. That's the kind of price that you have to pay to get ML talent in the international market these days. Most of Vasquez's skill set might leave something to be desired, but he has no holes in his game, and actually features a couple of dominating pitches, being his knuckleball and 4-seam fastball. He won't be winning any awards in his career, but Toronto can expect to get 50-60 solid, unspectacular innings per season out of this guy for cheap.
Those who cringe at the amount of money that gets splashed around in the international market might point to Vasquez, and Philidelphia's signing of Diory Alburquerque as cringe-worthy. But, the question needs to be asked - What else are they going to spend their prospect budget on? Alas, this is an argument for another day. As for Alburquerque, (I love typing out that name!), he projects to be another setup B type of talent, who should "max" out at 40-50 IP per season. This 18 year old's first pitch, a 4-seam fastball, could top out at an elite level, but his other two pitches (cut FB, curve) as well as the rest of his skill set, project to be decidedly pedestrian ML stuff.
It looks like Boston might have gotten better value for their $9.6 M than Toronto and Philly for their $10.6 M and $10.1 M. With the signing of 18 year old Panamanian Al Javier to a Major League deal, Boston has picked up a setup guy who's skill-set and durability looks to top out at a higher level thank Vazquez or Alburquerque. He projects to be able to pitch up to 100 IP, and has the skills to make them count. His two pitches, a 4-seamer and change up project to be dominating and good. His splits might be only average, and he might not get good velocity, but he should have good control and (very important for a pitcher in Boston!) looks to be a decent groundballer. Overall, this looks to be money well spent for Boston.
By signing Ramon Nomo to a $9.1 M deal with a spring training invite, it looks like Montgomery has picked up a pretty good value. This 20 year old Japanese starting pitcher projects to have some good enough stuff to be a decent back of the rotation type of starter or long reliever. At this point in his development, he could handle ML duties as a LRB or mopup guy, but with a bit of seasoning in the minors, he could turn out to be something a bit more valuable. It looks like he should be able to eat innings if called upon, and although he'll never be able to blow pitches by ML batters, the rest of his skill set should be able to make him at least effective at keeping his team in the game.
El Paso are please to not have wasted a good chunk of their prospect cash by signing Juan Moraga. This 18 year old Cuban defector signed a minor league contract with a spring training invite and a $9 M bonus. Considering how terrible El Paso's international scouts are, they should count themselves lucky to have seen any prospects worth signing at all. Moraga is definitely an intriguing prospect. He has ML power already, and that should improve to world class power. He projects to having a very good eye for the strike zone, and despite being a RHB, he seems to have a better ability at the plate against right-handed pitching than left. he does have a couple of weaknesses, mainly that he will strike out a lot, and also his glove might not end up to be satisfactory for ML right field duties. However, right field isn't a bad place to hide a bad glove, and his range and arm should be more than adequate for the position. All in all, this was a good move by El Paso's management, to be able to get something of value from the international market so late in the season, and with such a skeleton crew of international scouts that they have.
Next on our list might be one of the best value signings from the IFA market so far this season. By only paying $6.9 M with a minor league deal to secure the services of the 18 year old Cuban defector first baseman Vin Perez, Vancouver might just have landed themselves a potentially decent ML starter for a bargain basement price. This left-handed batter projects to have 30 hr potential, and his OBP could hover around .400. There is a real potential for this guy to average around .850 in OPS. What else can I say? Although he's a LHB, it looks like he should be able to handle left-handed pitching well enough to not need to platoon him, and his contact ability should keep him from striking out too much. His only knock is that he might not end up with the durability to start every game over a 162 game schedule, and that he probably won't ever be a 50 hr hitter. He should rack up the doubles though, so it still looks like Vancouver might have locked up a hitter to fill in the # 3 or 4 slot in their batting order for what relatively amounts to peanuts!
For $5.8 M, San Francisco inked 19 year old Irish OF Stan Morton to a minor league deal. Although he is a switch hitter, that ability is wasted, because he will only have the ability to hit left-handed pitching effectively. He has speed to burn, and also has good power at the plate, so the money spent on this guy is not too bad, considering that he might just top out as a bench/platoon player. I might be proved wrong though - San Fran could end up starting him in the Bigs, since he does have a good eye for the strike zone, and it looks like he might end up killing versus lefties. His batting average probably won't be good, but his OPS might get to .800 some seasons, so he's not all bad. Plus he'll play a gold glove corner outfield.
Rivaling Vin Perez for value might be the signing of Maicer Castro. This 18 year old Venezuelan starting pitcher signed a minor league deal with Salem for a paltry $5.7 M. He looks to have all of the skills to be a solid # 3 starter. He projects to have decent abilities across the board, with the exception of the fact that he looks to be a flyball pitcher in the end. Perhaps his ability against lefthanded batting might limit his effectiveness, and he could run into injury trouble in his career, but with so little spent to get his name on a contract, Salem has little to lose.
By getting Dominican 2b Carlos Palmeiro to sign a minor league deal with a spring training invite for a mere $5.1 M, Florida have also gotten themselves a nice bargain. It looks like Palmeiro should be able to handle ML 2b duties, and his offensive abilities should be good enough to justify him taking up a spot on a ML roster. His hitting abilities versus right-handed pitching might not get to the point where he will hit for a good average, but his speed and decent eye should help him get on base by legging out infield hits and earning walks. He'll probably never come close to 20 home runs, but who expects power hitting from the middle infield anyway? He has some good tools in his box, such as a decent ability to get the bat on the ball, the aforementioned speed and base-running ability, and he'll be able to bunt with the best of them. Combine that with a good ability to hit left handed pitching and solid defense, and Florida has themselves a decent prospect for the money.
Also filed under the "bargain" heading is San Francisco's signing of Dominican 18 year old RHP J.P. Peguero. By getting him into the fold at $4.2 M for a minor league deal, San Francisco might have picked up an effective bullpen arm for an extremely low price. His ability to pitch against left-handed batting might not ever be dominant, but he projects to shut righties down pretty effectively. It also looks like he could end up with good command of the strike zone, and has three solid pitches. On the down side, injuries could hamper his development, and he has the undesirable combination of low velocity and is a flyball pitcher. That spells homeruns allowed to me. However, for the low price that was paid for him, this guy will provide solid, but unspectacular numbers for his team, as long as he stays healthy.
SEASON 20 DRAFT RECAP
DRAFT ANALYSIS
A.L. North
Ottawa Hosers
The Hosers are making a playoff push and at this time haven’t been focusing their resources on acquiring new prospects. Their first round pick went to Baltimore as compensation for the Jesus Astacio signing. The first selection for the Hosers was a sandwich pick at #49 where they selected Trenidad Tejada, a marginal 5’5” high schooler without much offensive promise. There wasn’t much hope for Ottawa this time around, and they didn’t pull off any surprises.
Grade: D
Syracuse Blue Sox
The Blue Sox signed Jolbert Saenz and Ed Hurst and put themselves in a similar position to Ottawa. Leaving themselves virtually no money for signing young players, the Syracuse draft was mostly about rolling the dice trying to find some bargain arms that slipped through the cracks. They once again chose pitchers with their first seven picks, but the likelihood that lefty Antonio Moore can become more than a serviceable depth arm or that Nolan Kirwan can pitch to major league hitters is fairly slim.
Grade: D+
Toronto Trout
With the 17th pick in the draft, the Trout selected left fielder Santiago Crespo, whose skill set is heavily reliant on his ability to generate runs. With better than average speed and power, Crespo could be a heart of the order bat one day. His drawbacks are that he may be challenged to hit left handed pitching, and the reality that he’ll never be a great defender. He does represent above average offensive potential for his draft position. The Trout subsequently chose some pitchers with slim chances of reaching the professional ranks. They’re hoping to hit the international market to augment this season’s youth crop.
Grade: B
Trenton Terror Hawks
Trenton chose relief pitcher Mike Champion with the 19th pick and catcher/DH Gene Bell with the 42nd choice. Champion throws a hard sinker and while he seems able and willing to run out for an inning every day, scouts doubt whether he has the stuff to be an elite level closer. Bell is perhaps the best pure hitter drafted this season, and the Terror Hawks were happy to see him drop as far as he did. Many clubs were scared off by his injury history and others pointed out that despite his unparalleled bat, his defensive skills are so poor that he’ll be a liability wherever he plays in the field. A catcher by trade, his average throwing arm is down-graded by his inability to call a game. Probably a DH in the long run, his bat will certainly make waves.
Grade: B+
A.L. East
Boston Red Sox
This time around, the Red Sox started out with a couple of questionable selections with pitchers Jamie Chamberlain and Tony Camp. Both have problems with control and consistency and coming out of college, they have a bit less time to work on discovering some more redeeming skills. The Red Sox did a little bit better with their next two picks, as infielders Aaron Alexander and Rob Ramsey should provide solid defense to go along with alliteration. Alexander has great speed and both are good enough contact hitters to merit consideration for playing time at any level. Neither shows much power, however, which reflects Boston’s draft this season.
Grade: C-
Durham County Ramblers
The Ramblers have long suffered through years of mediocre pitching and their ballpark certainly doesn’t help on that score. At the #3 slot this season, they may have found a future staff ace in 6’4” righty Dan Price. Price has the make up of a future all-star and with outstanding control and no glaring flaws, if anyone can succeed pitching in Durham he looks like the perfect candidate. After Price, the Ramblers selected Ed Slocumb and Grover Blowers both of whom have an outside chance of finding their way into the bullpen. They also took a few solid defense-only players who could contribute off the bench. Really, only one pick matters this season, and Durham will soon find out if the Price is right.
Grade: A
Jacksonville Sunbirds
With the first overall selection in this year’s draft, the sunbirds chose shortstop Walt Sirotka, a complete ballplayer who boasts a dangerous bat as well as defensive acumen. With good speed, a strong arm and the reputation of a clutch performer Sirotka should be a steady major leaguer for a long time. They followed this pick up with the selection of catcher Lon Christopher and pitcher Glenn Porzio. Solid behind the plate, Christopher has yet to sign a contract and may have other options to consider. Porzio appears to be a decent pitcher, but his skill-ceiling may be lower than the Sunbirds would like. Not a bad draft for Jacksonville, but some feel that they could have scored a little higher.
Grade: B+
New York Crunch
With the 16th pick the Crunch were glad to see outfielder Tony Stanley still available. With a natural approach at the plate, Stanley has a sweet swing and a great feel for the strike zone. He doesn’t hit for much power, but he should certainly be an offensive sparkplug as he does everything else well. Hitting well for average would project him as a table-setter for the heart of the order bats to cash in. It remains to be seen how he’ll fare defensively, but Stanley is a good piece for New York’s future. Pitchers Pat Incaviglia and Otis Bowels are easy fodder for lefty hitters and may or may not be able to overcome that hurdle. From this crop, Stanley is really the only name that will generate buzz.
Grade: B-
A.L. South
Charlotte Designated Drinkers
The only piece of real significance for the D.D’s in this season’s draft was first round back-stopper Tony Park. This pick neatly addresses a need for Charlotte, where fans are growing weary of the Robert Roberts/Nigel Valentine tandem behind the plate. At 18 years of age, Park is likely still a couple of seasons away, but he easily becomes the most promising offensive catcher in the organization. He has a scorching throwing arm as well… a decent value for his draft position.
Grade: B+
Florida GATORs
Picking at the 28th slot, Florida took pitcher Todd Chatwood, who they hope will be looked back on as a diamond in the rough. Chatwood is certainly rough at this point, without much control or velocity on his varied arsenal of pitches. The rest of this season’s picks for the GATORs are nominal at best without a standout in the bunch from either an offensive or defensive standpoint. Versatile fielder Dickie Stokes has the best chance at climbing to a high level, but as a bench player to be sure. Not a very promising draft.
Grade: F (sorry)
Louisville Lobsters
Despite a later drafting position, the Lobsters found a serviceable arm in righty Mel Grant, who shows good control and could be a steady late inning presence if he can turn his cut fastball into a money pitch. Not a hard chucker by closer’s standards, Grant could turn into a situation reliever, capable of throwing every day. Louisville also landed outfielder Joshua Malone, who has a sweet swing and good bat control. Not a natural power hitter and without great speed or fielding prowess, Malone will need to hit for high batting average to make himself a useful offensive weapon.
Grade: B-
Nashville Catfish
With a heavy focus on pitching, the Catfish selected 18 yr old lefty Jason Jameson a Boston high-schooler with a promising pedigree including a sharp fastball. Some project him to end up in the bullpen, but regardless of what his role is Jameson should one day make an impact for Nashville. Second rounder Derek Bonine can make radar guns second-guess themselves, but he's quite wild and despite owning right-handed hitters, he gets slapped around mercilessly by lefties, perhaps limiting his long-term usefulness.
Grade: B-
A.L. West
Las Vegas Numa Numa
This time around, the Numa Numa decided to focus on finding capable defensive players, and drafted four shortstops with their first five picks. Top selection R.J. Moreno is an athletic player and a good contact hitter, but his lanky frame might hinder his range and see him shift over to third eventually. Steven Bird, Justin Sanders and Galahad Andrews all display strong defensive ability, without showing much upside at the plate. On the flipside, is catcher Dee Dee Jenner, who has a natural home run swing and comes out of WSU as a major league ready offensive talent. Jenner has a decent arm behind the plate, but really lacks the game-calling smarts that many pitchers rely on and as such could wind up as a DH. He hits lefties better than most current major leaguers and represents a sound offensive selection from the 45th pick in the draft.
Grade: B
Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns
With the 31st pick in the draft, OKC selected pitcher Jacque Nicholas. The 21 year old righty has great control and throws a good fastball. He figures to work his way into the bullpen for the Clowns and could potentially be a useful piece. Second rounder Bubba Gibbons has an outstanding fastball and throws four pitches well. If he can eventually learn to command his arsenal he could wind up as another piece of the puzzle. Not bad results from mediocre draft positioning.
Grade: B-
Sacramento Sanguillens
This season, Sacramento couldn’t pass on stud second bagger Pat Baldelli. Don’t be fooled by Baldelli’s slight build, he’s one of the best natural hitting prospects to surface in recent history. While he doesn’t possess game-changing power, he should still be able to knock a few over the wall to compliment his keen eye at the plate and a good line-drive swing to all fields. Dynamic hitting skills combined with smart base-running and a sound defensive game should give the Sanguillens another blue-chipper to build around. 39th pick Reagan Beaulac is a smart catcher with decent power, who could develop into a starter one day. Despite his talent, there are those who doubt the passion that Beaulac brings to the game, and perhaps it will take just the right coaching to get the most from the solid backstop. Second rounders Terry Lee and Steven Franco give Sacramento some more depth, the former an inning eating arm and the latter a slick fielder with a decent eye at the plate. Not much more the Sanguillens could have hoped for from this draft.
Grade: A
Scottsdale Fighting Chokes
Starting the draft with four pitchers, the Chokes are seriously addressing their future needs. First rounder Harry McEnerney is a pure talent with a first rate slider and a bright future. He had a reputation as someone who likes to party, so there’s some slight concern with his off-field behavior affecting his professionalism. Young Harry is only 18, so with the right guidance he should become a top tier major league pitcher. Second rounders Mark George and Manny Adams have far less natural talent than McEnerney, but with some hard work either of them could turn into effective ML pitchers. George has a durable arm and throws a great curveball, but he suffers against lefties and his overall stuff is fairly average. Adams has much better control and composure, also relying on his curveball as a primary pitch, but will need to avoid the long-ball if he’s going to succeed in the long term. The Chokes drafted three pitchers to watch going forward.
Grade: A-
N.L. North
Chicago Crushers
After the McKay Dunham debacle from season 19, it was very important to the Crushers to make the most of the #4 pick in this season’s draft. With speedy center fielder Carson Cannon they’ve done just that! Cannon has the potential to be an all-around 5-tool player for Chicago, as he’s already blessed with good speed (both on the base path and in the outfield) to go with a great contact bat, good power and a great glove. Cannon has a very promising career ahead of him. Second rounder Andres Perez is a solid second baseman with good speed and fielding instincts, though his average bat may hinder his progress. Third rounder Vinny Lowry is an enigmatic outfielder, boasting great speed, power and other good bat skills. Not a great fielder, Lowry is also reminiscent of Mark Reynolds, and is such a poor contact hitter that he could set strikeout records if given enough at bats. It will be interesting to see if he can overcome some of his challenges. Overall, aside from the lack of pitching help, the Crushers have to feel decent about this year’s draft. Grade: A
Detroit Tiger Sharks
Top pick Delmon Grimsley is a top tier defensive shortstop, in fact, he’s such a star fielder that he’ll force people to notice him despite some fairly average offensive skills. He does hit lefties fairly well, so he may one day be a platoon player with many a late inning fielding assignment. The Tiger Sharks then went on a run of pitchers, with towering Brendan Costello and his super-sinker the most promising of the bunch. A groundball pitcher, Costello throws hard and low and might have closer’s stuff. The Tigers have a couple of useful pieces to work with here.
Grade: B
Montreal Maroons
With a mere pittance allocated for scouting, it’s no surprise that the Maroons didn’t really make a splash on draft day. First rounder Ronnie Tyson does some things well, but many feel that his ceiling is fairly low. Second rounder “A Man Named” Gail Rogers has good control, and could potentially be a bullpen arm, but there are some doubts about his overall skill-set as well. The Maroons have done a little better with the International route and are still hoping to find another youngster overseas.
Grade: D
Philadelphia Pheremoniacs
First rounder Dave Boswell is another in the slick-fielding/light-hitting mold. He could be a major leaguer if his team is content to take a .200 hitter at the bottom of the order to put his excellent defense in the field. Catcher Armando Villanueva is a solid option, with ML-ready power and good plate patience. He has the potential to be an adequate backstop, though he’ll likely never be truly great defensively, and he also has trouble hitting the southpaws, making him a potential platoon candidate. “All-or-nothing” Guy Zimmerman is a stiff outfielder with a free swing and natural power. He seems destined for AAA greatness, as his contact skills will crumble against ML pitching. Overall, the World Champs can’t be terribly excited about this seasons draft.
Grade: C
N.L. East
Augusta Capitols
The Capitols started the season by making a number of big splashes on the free agent market, thus expunging their top choice in the draft. They started with the 43rd pick and took one of the most puzzling selections in this season’s draft class: Uber-talented Michigan high-school catcher Doug Milner is one of the brightest young talents in the country, however he’s lucky to be alive after he was severely hurt in a car crash last summer. Milner operates with only one lung, and several of his organs aren’t functioning to a normal level. Some doctors said that he would never play again, but he’s been cleared to resume baseball activities (monitored by his personal physician) provided that he doesn’t aggravate his condition. Milner has a devastating power stroke and would likely have become one of baseball’s true elite sluggers if he could play a full season. A real student of the game, he also demonstrates brilliant depth behind the plate with his pitch calling and has a strong and accurate arm. Augusta has themselves a secret weapon on a respirator, and they’ll likely be itching for Milner to get into as many games as possible. He’s really the only pick with substantial upside for Augusta…
Grade: C
Baltimore Barons
After addressing pitching for the past couple of seasons (resulting in a couple of tremendously bright young arms in their future), the Barons chose center fielder Norm Schmidt with the 8th pick in the draft. Schmidt’s bat certainly will need to develop for him to be a star hitter. He’s a pure contact hitter, not likely to draw a walk, with moderate power and far more successful against left handed pitching. The clincher with Schmidt is his defense. He could be the best defensive outfielder to come along in years! He patrols center field like a gazelle, and his arm is second to none. The Barons then chose hard throwing lefty Hal McMasters, a solid two pitch guy likely on the fast track to the Baltimore bullpen. First baseman Orlando Sanchez was a steal at pick #83, with great natural hitting instincts and a sweet swing. Sanchez will never compete for a home run title, but he sees the strike zone extremely well and has extra base power to all fields. Baltimore should be fairly satisfied with their bounty in what seems to be a fairly thin draft class.
Grade: A
Cincinnati Red Army
With the 12th and 55th picks, the Red Army chose a couple of pitchers receiving mixed reviews. Top choice Chipper Edwards has a strong arm, and a magnificent sinker. He’s a true groundball pitcher with near perfect control, however, there are some concerns that he’s prone to blow-ups (especially late in games) and Cincy will need to figure out how to get the most of Chipper’s skills. Sandwich pick Brian Damon is a curve-ball master with a 5-pitch arsenal and some good zip. There are concerns that he can be a bit wild at times and also that he can’t go too deep into games. Perhaps Damon is another bullpen candidate, unless he can work on his stamina levels. This year’s draft class will need some decent coaching in the next few years if they’re to enjoy long term success.
Grade:C+
Washington Swamp Cats
Without a pick until #26, the Swamp Cats should be pleased with their results. Second bagger Bob Forbes is a complete player with great base-running skills, good plate patience and a sound defensive game. He won’t be a star, but he should be an above average player and a good fit in Washington. Defensive infielder Kyle Hicks is another potentially useful piece, perhaps more on the defensive side. Hicks isn’t a deep threat, and as a contact hitter, he has a bit of trouble against right-handed pitching. His versatility may be his saving grace. The Swamp Cats also selected catcher Eddie Gosling, one of the soundest defensive catchers in the draft. Not really known for his bat, Gosling does boast decent power in spurts when given an opportunity.
Grade: B+
N.L. South
Atlanta World Police
The World Police didn’t pick until spot #33 and they never had much cause to celebrate this time around. Top selection Nolan Crandell is a moderately skilled outfielder with mediocre talent at the plate. Atlanta doesn’t really seem to have hit with any of their picks this season. They’re a team competing for post-season glory, so perhaps they can wait a few years for the next big thing.
Grade: F
El Paso Blancos
The top three picks for El Paso this season were American-born infielders of Latin-American heritage. Shortstop Matty Polanco is a good all-around ballplayer, with some power at the plate and a slick glove. He hits righties exceptionally well, though scouts say that he’ll struggle to hit for average and his range may not be suited to playing short long term. Range is not a problem for speedy second baseman Jorge Santana, who is a slick fielder, a fluid natural base-runner and a good contact hitter. Not a power hitter, Santana is a free swinger who doesn’t like to draw a walk, so he’ll need to figure out other ways to get on base to employ his speed game. Infielder Geraldo Estrada is a solid young contact hitter who has no major flaws in his game. Perhaps best suited as a third baseman, Estrada hits to all fields and has good baseball instincts. He doesn’t have a wealth of natural talent, so he’ll need to be in a good situation if he’s to succeed. No blue-chippers this time around for the Blancos, but they did draft three useful and skilled players.
Grade: B
Mexico City Jalapenos
Ninth overall the Jalapenos selected second baseman Buzz Hollins, a gritty hard-working throwback type ball-player who will be known more for hustle than skill. Hollins has decent range at his position, but can be prone to errors at second and might do well with a switch to the outfield. A slash hitter with good plate composure, Hollins doesn’t chase bad pitches and though he isn’t blessed with great speed, he’s a smart base-runner who makes the most of his talents. Not a natural power hitter, Buzz should still be able to knock 10-15 dingers per year. He’s really the only player with decent upside for Mexico City this time around, as pitcher Bert Tate is a bit of a longshot.
Grade: C+
Monterrey Massacre
With the 2nd overall pick, the Massacre went for Stuffy Haynes, an allergy sufferer who is a more of a great athlete than a great ballplayer. There are hopes that he can develop into an impact performer, with above average power, decent speed and good range at second base. He needs work in all departments, but he is only 18 years old, and time will tell if he becomes a serviceable player or a great one. Many scouts feel that picking Haynes at #2 was a bit of a reach, but they’ll also agree that landing Jean Berkman at #25 was a huge steal for Monterrey. Berkman is a fierce competitor with a feared bat and power to all fields. He might strike out more than his share, but he should make up for it with run production and defense. Either Haynes or Berkman will need to find a new position down the road if both top Massacre draft picks are to become successful.
Grade: B
N.L. West
Helena Phantom der Nacht
This year’s draft was a bit of a throwaway for Helena. With a mid-late first rounder (#23) and their next pick at #97, they didn’t really have access to the top talent and they bore the brunt of a very thin talent level in this season’s draft class. Top selection Vic Martinez is a 22 yr old pitcher who already throws at a AAA level, but some scouts feel that he’s already peaked. If Martinez can work on his control and improve his fastball, he could wind up as a quality major league hurler, but much hinges on the next couple season’s of his development. The rest of the draft was very forgettable for the Phantom der Nacht, as they’ve had much better luck with their international signings this season.
Grade: D-
L.A. Dead Bunnies
The Dead Bunnies took outfielder/first baseman Miguel Mota with the 22nd pick in the draft. Mota shows a fair amount of natural hitting talent that could translate into a heart of the order bat for L.A. With 30 home run potential and a good eye at the plate, Mota’s main weakness is defense, where he’ll have a tough time if the Bunnies need him in the outfield. Sandwich pick Al Maduro is a fairly smooth outfielder with great range, but he swings a fairly unimpressive bat. Second rounder Horace Scott looks like a great defensive addition, and although he’ll rarely connect with any power, he could become a good enough contact hitter to be a useful player for L.A.
Grade: B-
San Fransisco Streets
Addressing what they deem to be their top need, the Streets selected pitchers with 16 of their first 17 selections in this year’s draft. Top pick Paul Presley has the potential to be a top of the rotation workhorse in San Fran. With great control and a gritty competitive nature, Presley challenges hitters and can pitch deep into games. He’ll need a few seasons to mature, and the Streets hope that he’ll eventually be a leader for them. Second rounder Cooper Gumbert also has some promise, showing both a great curveball a nasty slider, he has a bit of work to do against lefties and probably figures in the bullpen eventually.
Grade: B+
Vancouver Vampire Bats
The V-Bats selected Marco Kelly, a soft throwing righty with decent control of his five pitches. Kelly needs to work on his stamina if he’s going to remain a starter, though he has the makeup to become a useful arm in a few seasons if he’s well coached. With their second round pick Vancouver took Jack Hackman, a solid if unspectacular hitter who’s lack of fielding prowess would best serve him as a DH in the AL. There’s some potential in these picks, but nothing ground breaking.
Grade: C+
A.L. North
Ottawa Hosers
The Hosers are making a playoff push and at this time haven’t been focusing their resources on acquiring new prospects. Their first round pick went to Baltimore as compensation for the Jesus Astacio signing. The first selection for the Hosers was a sandwich pick at #49 where they selected Trenidad Tejada, a marginal 5’5” high schooler without much offensive promise. There wasn’t much hope for Ottawa this time around, and they didn’t pull off any surprises.
Grade: D
Syracuse Blue Sox
The Blue Sox signed Jolbert Saenz and Ed Hurst and put themselves in a similar position to Ottawa. Leaving themselves virtually no money for signing young players, the Syracuse draft was mostly about rolling the dice trying to find some bargain arms that slipped through the cracks. They once again chose pitchers with their first seven picks, but the likelihood that lefty Antonio Moore can become more than a serviceable depth arm or that Nolan Kirwan can pitch to major league hitters is fairly slim.
Grade: D+
Toronto Trout
With the 17th pick in the draft, the Trout selected left fielder Santiago Crespo, whose skill set is heavily reliant on his ability to generate runs. With better than average speed and power, Crespo could be a heart of the order bat one day. His drawbacks are that he may be challenged to hit left handed pitching, and the reality that he’ll never be a great defender. He does represent above average offensive potential for his draft position. The Trout subsequently chose some pitchers with slim chances of reaching the professional ranks. They’re hoping to hit the international market to augment this season’s youth crop.
Grade: B
Trenton Terror Hawks
Trenton chose relief pitcher Mike Champion with the 19th pick and catcher/DH Gene Bell with the 42nd choice. Champion throws a hard sinker and while he seems able and willing to run out for an inning every day, scouts doubt whether he has the stuff to be an elite level closer. Bell is perhaps the best pure hitter drafted this season, and the Terror Hawks were happy to see him drop as far as he did. Many clubs were scared off by his injury history and others pointed out that despite his unparalleled bat, his defensive skills are so poor that he’ll be a liability wherever he plays in the field. A catcher by trade, his average throwing arm is down-graded by his inability to call a game. Probably a DH in the long run, his bat will certainly make waves.
Grade: B+
A.L. East
Boston Red Sox
This time around, the Red Sox started out with a couple of questionable selections with pitchers Jamie Chamberlain and Tony Camp. Both have problems with control and consistency and coming out of college, they have a bit less time to work on discovering some more redeeming skills. The Red Sox did a little bit better with their next two picks, as infielders Aaron Alexander and Rob Ramsey should provide solid defense to go along with alliteration. Alexander has great speed and both are good enough contact hitters to merit consideration for playing time at any level. Neither shows much power, however, which reflects Boston’s draft this season.
Grade: C-
Durham County Ramblers
The Ramblers have long suffered through years of mediocre pitching and their ballpark certainly doesn’t help on that score. At the #3 slot this season, they may have found a future staff ace in 6’4” righty Dan Price. Price has the make up of a future all-star and with outstanding control and no glaring flaws, if anyone can succeed pitching in Durham he looks like the perfect candidate. After Price, the Ramblers selected Ed Slocumb and Grover Blowers both of whom have an outside chance of finding their way into the bullpen. They also took a few solid defense-only players who could contribute off the bench. Really, only one pick matters this season, and Durham will soon find out if the Price is right.
Grade: A
Jacksonville Sunbirds
With the first overall selection in this year’s draft, the sunbirds chose shortstop Walt Sirotka, a complete ballplayer who boasts a dangerous bat as well as defensive acumen. With good speed, a strong arm and the reputation of a clutch performer Sirotka should be a steady major leaguer for a long time. They followed this pick up with the selection of catcher Lon Christopher and pitcher Glenn Porzio. Solid behind the plate, Christopher has yet to sign a contract and may have other options to consider. Porzio appears to be a decent pitcher, but his skill-ceiling may be lower than the Sunbirds would like. Not a bad draft for Jacksonville, but some feel that they could have scored a little higher.
Grade: B+
New York Crunch
With the 16th pick the Crunch were glad to see outfielder Tony Stanley still available. With a natural approach at the plate, Stanley has a sweet swing and a great feel for the strike zone. He doesn’t hit for much power, but he should certainly be an offensive sparkplug as he does everything else well. Hitting well for average would project him as a table-setter for the heart of the order bats to cash in. It remains to be seen how he’ll fare defensively, but Stanley is a good piece for New York’s future. Pitchers Pat Incaviglia and Otis Bowels are easy fodder for lefty hitters and may or may not be able to overcome that hurdle. From this crop, Stanley is really the only name that will generate buzz.
Grade: B-
A.L. South
Charlotte Designated Drinkers
The only piece of real significance for the D.D’s in this season’s draft was first round back-stopper Tony Park. This pick neatly addresses a need for Charlotte, where fans are growing weary of the Robert Roberts/Nigel Valentine tandem behind the plate. At 18 years of age, Park is likely still a couple of seasons away, but he easily becomes the most promising offensive catcher in the organization. He has a scorching throwing arm as well… a decent value for his draft position.
Grade: B+
Florida GATORs
Picking at the 28th slot, Florida took pitcher Todd Chatwood, who they hope will be looked back on as a diamond in the rough. Chatwood is certainly rough at this point, without much control or velocity on his varied arsenal of pitches. The rest of this season’s picks for the GATORs are nominal at best without a standout in the bunch from either an offensive or defensive standpoint. Versatile fielder Dickie Stokes has the best chance at climbing to a high level, but as a bench player to be sure. Not a very promising draft.
Grade: F (sorry)
Louisville Lobsters
Despite a later drafting position, the Lobsters found a serviceable arm in righty Mel Grant, who shows good control and could be a steady late inning presence if he can turn his cut fastball into a money pitch. Not a hard chucker by closer’s standards, Grant could turn into a situation reliever, capable of throwing every day. Louisville also landed outfielder Joshua Malone, who has a sweet swing and good bat control. Not a natural power hitter and without great speed or fielding prowess, Malone will need to hit for high batting average to make himself a useful offensive weapon.
Grade: B-
Nashville Catfish
With a heavy focus on pitching, the Catfish selected 18 yr old lefty Jason Jameson a Boston high-schooler with a promising pedigree including a sharp fastball. Some project him to end up in the bullpen, but regardless of what his role is Jameson should one day make an impact for Nashville. Second rounder Derek Bonine can make radar guns second-guess themselves, but he's quite wild and despite owning right-handed hitters, he gets slapped around mercilessly by lefties, perhaps limiting his long-term usefulness.
Grade: B-
A.L. West
Las Vegas Numa Numa
This time around, the Numa Numa decided to focus on finding capable defensive players, and drafted four shortstops with their first five picks. Top selection R.J. Moreno is an athletic player and a good contact hitter, but his lanky frame might hinder his range and see him shift over to third eventually. Steven Bird, Justin Sanders and Galahad Andrews all display strong defensive ability, without showing much upside at the plate. On the flipside, is catcher Dee Dee Jenner, who has a natural home run swing and comes out of WSU as a major league ready offensive talent. Jenner has a decent arm behind the plate, but really lacks the game-calling smarts that many pitchers rely on and as such could wind up as a DH. He hits lefties better than most current major leaguers and represents a sound offensive selection from the 45th pick in the draft.
Grade: B
Oklahoma City Rodeo Clowns
With the 31st pick in the draft, OKC selected pitcher Jacque Nicholas. The 21 year old righty has great control and throws a good fastball. He figures to work his way into the bullpen for the Clowns and could potentially be a useful piece. Second rounder Bubba Gibbons has an outstanding fastball and throws four pitches well. If he can eventually learn to command his arsenal he could wind up as another piece of the puzzle. Not bad results from mediocre draft positioning.
Grade: B-
Sacramento Sanguillens
This season, Sacramento couldn’t pass on stud second bagger Pat Baldelli. Don’t be fooled by Baldelli’s slight build, he’s one of the best natural hitting prospects to surface in recent history. While he doesn’t possess game-changing power, he should still be able to knock a few over the wall to compliment his keen eye at the plate and a good line-drive swing to all fields. Dynamic hitting skills combined with smart base-running and a sound defensive game should give the Sanguillens another blue-chipper to build around. 39th pick Reagan Beaulac is a smart catcher with decent power, who could develop into a starter one day. Despite his talent, there are those who doubt the passion that Beaulac brings to the game, and perhaps it will take just the right coaching to get the most from the solid backstop. Second rounders Terry Lee and Steven Franco give Sacramento some more depth, the former an inning eating arm and the latter a slick fielder with a decent eye at the plate. Not much more the Sanguillens could have hoped for from this draft.
Grade: A
Scottsdale Fighting Chokes
Starting the draft with four pitchers, the Chokes are seriously addressing their future needs. First rounder Harry McEnerney is a pure talent with a first rate slider and a bright future. He had a reputation as someone who likes to party, so there’s some slight concern with his off-field behavior affecting his professionalism. Young Harry is only 18, so with the right guidance he should become a top tier major league pitcher. Second rounders Mark George and Manny Adams have far less natural talent than McEnerney, but with some hard work either of them could turn into effective ML pitchers. George has a durable arm and throws a great curveball, but he suffers against lefties and his overall stuff is fairly average. Adams has much better control and composure, also relying on his curveball as a primary pitch, but will need to avoid the long-ball if he’s going to succeed in the long term. The Chokes drafted three pitchers to watch going forward.
Grade: A-
N.L. North
Chicago Crushers
After the McKay Dunham debacle from season 19, it was very important to the Crushers to make the most of the #4 pick in this season’s draft. With speedy center fielder Carson Cannon they’ve done just that! Cannon has the potential to be an all-around 5-tool player for Chicago, as he’s already blessed with good speed (both on the base path and in the outfield) to go with a great contact bat, good power and a great glove. Cannon has a very promising career ahead of him. Second rounder Andres Perez is a solid second baseman with good speed and fielding instincts, though his average bat may hinder his progress. Third rounder Vinny Lowry is an enigmatic outfielder, boasting great speed, power and other good bat skills. Not a great fielder, Lowry is also reminiscent of Mark Reynolds, and is such a poor contact hitter that he could set strikeout records if given enough at bats. It will be interesting to see if he can overcome some of his challenges. Overall, aside from the lack of pitching help, the Crushers have to feel decent about this year’s draft. Grade: A
Detroit Tiger Sharks
Top pick Delmon Grimsley is a top tier defensive shortstop, in fact, he’s such a star fielder that he’ll force people to notice him despite some fairly average offensive skills. He does hit lefties fairly well, so he may one day be a platoon player with many a late inning fielding assignment. The Tiger Sharks then went on a run of pitchers, with towering Brendan Costello and his super-sinker the most promising of the bunch. A groundball pitcher, Costello throws hard and low and might have closer’s stuff. The Tigers have a couple of useful pieces to work with here.
Grade: B
Montreal Maroons
With a mere pittance allocated for scouting, it’s no surprise that the Maroons didn’t really make a splash on draft day. First rounder Ronnie Tyson does some things well, but many feel that his ceiling is fairly low. Second rounder “A Man Named” Gail Rogers has good control, and could potentially be a bullpen arm, but there are some doubts about his overall skill-set as well. The Maroons have done a little better with the International route and are still hoping to find another youngster overseas.
Grade: D
Philadelphia Pheremoniacs
First rounder Dave Boswell is another in the slick-fielding/light-hitting mold. He could be a major leaguer if his team is content to take a .200 hitter at the bottom of the order to put his excellent defense in the field. Catcher Armando Villanueva is a solid option, with ML-ready power and good plate patience. He has the potential to be an adequate backstop, though he’ll likely never be truly great defensively, and he also has trouble hitting the southpaws, making him a potential platoon candidate. “All-or-nothing” Guy Zimmerman is a stiff outfielder with a free swing and natural power. He seems destined for AAA greatness, as his contact skills will crumble against ML pitching. Overall, the World Champs can’t be terribly excited about this seasons draft.
Grade: C
N.L. East
Augusta Capitols
The Capitols started the season by making a number of big splashes on the free agent market, thus expunging their top choice in the draft. They started with the 43rd pick and took one of the most puzzling selections in this season’s draft class: Uber-talented Michigan high-school catcher Doug Milner is one of the brightest young talents in the country, however he’s lucky to be alive after he was severely hurt in a car crash last summer. Milner operates with only one lung, and several of his organs aren’t functioning to a normal level. Some doctors said that he would never play again, but he’s been cleared to resume baseball activities (monitored by his personal physician) provided that he doesn’t aggravate his condition. Milner has a devastating power stroke and would likely have become one of baseball’s true elite sluggers if he could play a full season. A real student of the game, he also demonstrates brilliant depth behind the plate with his pitch calling and has a strong and accurate arm. Augusta has themselves a secret weapon on a respirator, and they’ll likely be itching for Milner to get into as many games as possible. He’s really the only pick with substantial upside for Augusta…
Grade: C
Baltimore Barons
After addressing pitching for the past couple of seasons (resulting in a couple of tremendously bright young arms in their future), the Barons chose center fielder Norm Schmidt with the 8th pick in the draft. Schmidt’s bat certainly will need to develop for him to be a star hitter. He’s a pure contact hitter, not likely to draw a walk, with moderate power and far more successful against left handed pitching. The clincher with Schmidt is his defense. He could be the best defensive outfielder to come along in years! He patrols center field like a gazelle, and his arm is second to none. The Barons then chose hard throwing lefty Hal McMasters, a solid two pitch guy likely on the fast track to the Baltimore bullpen. First baseman Orlando Sanchez was a steal at pick #83, with great natural hitting instincts and a sweet swing. Sanchez will never compete for a home run title, but he sees the strike zone extremely well and has extra base power to all fields. Baltimore should be fairly satisfied with their bounty in what seems to be a fairly thin draft class.
Grade: A
Cincinnati Red Army
With the 12th and 55th picks, the Red Army chose a couple of pitchers receiving mixed reviews. Top choice Chipper Edwards has a strong arm, and a magnificent sinker. He’s a true groundball pitcher with near perfect control, however, there are some concerns that he’s prone to blow-ups (especially late in games) and Cincy will need to figure out how to get the most of Chipper’s skills. Sandwich pick Brian Damon is a curve-ball master with a 5-pitch arsenal and some good zip. There are concerns that he can be a bit wild at times and also that he can’t go too deep into games. Perhaps Damon is another bullpen candidate, unless he can work on his stamina levels. This year’s draft class will need some decent coaching in the next few years if they’re to enjoy long term success.
Grade:C+
Washington Swamp Cats
Without a pick until #26, the Swamp Cats should be pleased with their results. Second bagger Bob Forbes is a complete player with great base-running skills, good plate patience and a sound defensive game. He won’t be a star, but he should be an above average player and a good fit in Washington. Defensive infielder Kyle Hicks is another potentially useful piece, perhaps more on the defensive side. Hicks isn’t a deep threat, and as a contact hitter, he has a bit of trouble against right-handed pitching. His versatility may be his saving grace. The Swamp Cats also selected catcher Eddie Gosling, one of the soundest defensive catchers in the draft. Not really known for his bat, Gosling does boast decent power in spurts when given an opportunity.
Grade: B+
N.L. South
Atlanta World Police
The World Police didn’t pick until spot #33 and they never had much cause to celebrate this time around. Top selection Nolan Crandell is a moderately skilled outfielder with mediocre talent at the plate. Atlanta doesn’t really seem to have hit with any of their picks this season. They’re a team competing for post-season glory, so perhaps they can wait a few years for the next big thing.
Grade: F
El Paso Blancos
The top three picks for El Paso this season were American-born infielders of Latin-American heritage. Shortstop Matty Polanco is a good all-around ballplayer, with some power at the plate and a slick glove. He hits righties exceptionally well, though scouts say that he’ll struggle to hit for average and his range may not be suited to playing short long term. Range is not a problem for speedy second baseman Jorge Santana, who is a slick fielder, a fluid natural base-runner and a good contact hitter. Not a power hitter, Santana is a free swinger who doesn’t like to draw a walk, so he’ll need to figure out other ways to get on base to employ his speed game. Infielder Geraldo Estrada is a solid young contact hitter who has no major flaws in his game. Perhaps best suited as a third baseman, Estrada hits to all fields and has good baseball instincts. He doesn’t have a wealth of natural talent, so he’ll need to be in a good situation if he’s to succeed. No blue-chippers this time around for the Blancos, but they did draft three useful and skilled players.
Grade: B
Mexico City Jalapenos
Ninth overall the Jalapenos selected second baseman Buzz Hollins, a gritty hard-working throwback type ball-player who will be known more for hustle than skill. Hollins has decent range at his position, but can be prone to errors at second and might do well with a switch to the outfield. A slash hitter with good plate composure, Hollins doesn’t chase bad pitches and though he isn’t blessed with great speed, he’s a smart base-runner who makes the most of his talents. Not a natural power hitter, Buzz should still be able to knock 10-15 dingers per year. He’s really the only player with decent upside for Mexico City this time around, as pitcher Bert Tate is a bit of a longshot.
Grade: C+
Monterrey Massacre
With the 2nd overall pick, the Massacre went for Stuffy Haynes, an allergy sufferer who is a more of a great athlete than a great ballplayer. There are hopes that he can develop into an impact performer, with above average power, decent speed and good range at second base. He needs work in all departments, but he is only 18 years old, and time will tell if he becomes a serviceable player or a great one. Many scouts feel that picking Haynes at #2 was a bit of a reach, but they’ll also agree that landing Jean Berkman at #25 was a huge steal for Monterrey. Berkman is a fierce competitor with a feared bat and power to all fields. He might strike out more than his share, but he should make up for it with run production and defense. Either Haynes or Berkman will need to find a new position down the road if both top Massacre draft picks are to become successful.
Grade: B
N.L. West
Helena Phantom der Nacht
This year’s draft was a bit of a throwaway for Helena. With a mid-late first rounder (#23) and their next pick at #97, they didn’t really have access to the top talent and they bore the brunt of a very thin talent level in this season’s draft class. Top selection Vic Martinez is a 22 yr old pitcher who already throws at a AAA level, but some scouts feel that he’s already peaked. If Martinez can work on his control and improve his fastball, he could wind up as a quality major league hurler, but much hinges on the next couple season’s of his development. The rest of the draft was very forgettable for the Phantom der Nacht, as they’ve had much better luck with their international signings this season.
Grade: D-
L.A. Dead Bunnies
The Dead Bunnies took outfielder/first baseman Miguel Mota with the 22nd pick in the draft. Mota shows a fair amount of natural hitting talent that could translate into a heart of the order bat for L.A. With 30 home run potential and a good eye at the plate, Mota’s main weakness is defense, where he’ll have a tough time if the Bunnies need him in the outfield. Sandwich pick Al Maduro is a fairly smooth outfielder with great range, but he swings a fairly unimpressive bat. Second rounder Horace Scott looks like a great defensive addition, and although he’ll rarely connect with any power, he could become a good enough contact hitter to be a useful player for L.A.
Grade: B-
San Fransisco Streets
Addressing what they deem to be their top need, the Streets selected pitchers with 16 of their first 17 selections in this year’s draft. Top pick Paul Presley has the potential to be a top of the rotation workhorse in San Fran. With great control and a gritty competitive nature, Presley challenges hitters and can pitch deep into games. He’ll need a few seasons to mature, and the Streets hope that he’ll eventually be a leader for them. Second rounder Cooper Gumbert also has some promise, showing both a great curveball a nasty slider, he has a bit of work to do against lefties and probably figures in the bullpen eventually.
Grade: B+
Vancouver Vampire Bats
The V-Bats selected Marco Kelly, a soft throwing righty with decent control of his five pitches. Kelly needs to work on his stamina if he’s going to remain a starter, though he has the makeup to become a useful arm in a few seasons if he’s well coached. With their second round pick Vancouver took Jack Hackman, a solid if unspectacular hitter who’s lack of fielding prowess would best serve him as a DH in the AL. There’s some potential in these picks, but nothing ground breaking.
Grade: C+
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)